What are you reading in 2025?

I just finished reading Andrzej Sapkowski's The Last Wish, the first (sort of) book in The Witcher series of novels.

While I've been aware of the Witcher series for some time, I'd never actually partaken of any of its media prior to now, not having played the games nor having watched the Henry Cavill series. In the case of the former, it's because I've largely grown out of video games; for the latter, it was because I had a vague impression that I wanted to read the books rather than watch the live-action adaptation, since the books are—as a general rule—(almost) always better, and so are how I prefer to form my first impression.

(Apparently this is more of a guideline than a rule for me, as I've seen the totality of Tom Cruise and Alan Ritchson's takes on Jack Reacher without ever having read any of Lee Child's novels...and yet still picked one up when I came across it in a Little Free Library the other day).

Having read this through, I'm quite impressed. Sapkowski's protagonist, Geralt of Rivia (the eponymous witcher—i.e. professional monster slayer—after whom the series is named) cuts an interesting archetype. While his stoicism, perseverence in the face of both moral and mortal danger, and refusal to compromise on his beliefs are all archetypal in their presentation, Sapkowski never overcompensates for this by having Geralt lapse into angst or introspection. It wouldn't have taken much for Geralt to turn into another Byronic hero a la Drizzt Do'Urden, quietly resigning himself to a sense of isolation even as he performs a job that he knows must be done all while still nursing a faint hope that perhaps one day he might find fulfilling companionship. Instead, Geralt comes off as more down-to-earth, willing to engage in the irregular bouts of laughter when something seems ridiculous and the ocassional fling with a beautiful woman. It's a nice change from wistfully envying those who have a normal life and bemoaning fate for not having one.

On a slightly more technical note, I can't help but notice that Geralt also seems to exist as an archetype opposite that of the "spell-less ranger" which every so often sweeps through the D&D(-adjacent) community. Unlike Aragorn, Geralt uses magic regularly as part of his fighting style, along with various minor magical charms and trinkets.

What's interesting is that he's apparently the only one who does so. While the book makes it clear that there are other witchers—though it establishes early on that even among them he's special (witchers being made by taking young children and inducing artificial mutations that make them tougher, faster, and have sharper senses than ordinary humans, with Geralt having taken to the process better than most)—we never see one in the course of this story (or rather, any of the stories herein, as this is actually several tales told within a framing narrative).

The result is that Geralt is, essentially, a gish/red mage/magic knight-style character in a world where everyone else is either a mundane fighter or a full-on wizard or cleric. His magic lets him dance rings around the former, and his fighting prowess lets him overwhelm the latter...mostly, as Yennefer, the seductive enchantress who's set up as his love interest near the end of the book, showcases.

As for the world itself, it's notable how little we see of it here, and yet how much is suggested. Sapkowski is smart enough to understand that place names and politics are only as important as how well they serve as backdrops, i.e. how they set up the state of things that Geralt has to work within. To that end, being told a little goes a long way; I've often heard it said that bad GMs who dump too much information about their setting on their players are "frustrated novelists," but the implication that all of that worldbuilding belongs in a novel is put to the lie here. I've ranted before about writers who go too far in avoiding exposition, but Sapkowski is a person who knows how to do that without compromising the integrity of his work.

All in all, I can understand why this series became a hit, and I'm definitely looking forward to seeing what becomes of The Witcher.
What struck me about The Last Wish is just how rooted in folklore and fairytales it is. They might be subverted, but they're very much part of the weft and weave of the tales.

The goddess of defenestration never closes a door without opening a window.
Back when I was a librarian, my test of a dictionary was to see if it had defenestration in it.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Tey's "Franchise Affair" might be my all time favorite mystery and I loved "Miss Pym Disposes". They got me to try these ones by Upson. The other Grant ones demonstrated Tey could wordsmith and turn convention on its head with the best, but aren't ones I'll probably revisit.
We recently saw the play version of The Daughter of Time, which is a great adaptation and has also updated its historical information on Richard III from the book.

Read Breath of the Dragon, which is a slightly odd beast - it’s a wuxia fantasy written by Fonda Lee (as in Jade City) and Shannon Lee (no relation). Shannon is Bruce Lee’s last surviving child and the book is slightly based on his teachings, though it’s mostly references only - our protagonist is nicknamed the Little Dragon and uses the one inch punch at one point. It’s perfectly fine and quite well written, I’ll keep an eye out for the sequel.
 

I really need a new audiobook for my commute. I have kind of run out of WW2 era espionage books, and books about the history of video games, comics and RPGs. I need a really compelling nonfiction narrative but no true crime.
 

I really need a new audiobook for my commute. I have kind of run out of WW2 era espionage books, and books about the history of video games, comics and RPGs. I need a really compelling nonfiction narrative but no true crime.
For some reason I really enjoyed One Summer: America, 1927 by Bill Bryson as a commuting audiobook several years ago. I generally haven’t really enjoyed listening to Bryson’s voice otherwise, but that one somehow worked well for me.
 


I really need a new audiobook for my commute. I have kind of run out of WW2 era espionage books, and books about the history of video games, comics and RPGs. I need a really compelling nonfiction narrative but no true crime.
If you want an examination of how Spotify is evil: Mood Machine by Liz Pelly.

If you want a slightly-credulous take on orientalism and mysticism in the first half of the 20th century: Holy Men of the Electronic Age by Raphael Cormack.

I know you said "no true crime" but Murderland by Caroline Fraser is at least half about stuff other than serial killers--environmental concerns, Christian Science, I-90 through Seattle--and I found it an interesting if kinda scattershot read.
 





Remove ads

Top