Hmm ...
1. LOTR - extended versions only, and I also consider them to be a single movie
2. Ladyhawke - some of the most beautiful cinematography I have ever seen.
3. Hawk the Slayer ... I know, I know. But the character of Crow totally won me over. The rest I could do without.
4. The Five Deadly Venoms - a B-grade kung-fu movie that I loved the first time I saw it and have ever since.
5. Narnia - for all my complaints about the story changes it was well done.
Honoroable Mention: Clash of the Titans.