what is the best 3e module?

[pogre]

Bastions was well done I thought.

 

[Reika]

I agree. For dungeoncrawl, RttoEE is a great module. For more roleplaying, Witchfire Trilogy is excellent.

Depends on the group you have in RttToEE, I have a paladin whose player reads Shakespear before playing so he has proper inspiration for his char's verbosity, an LG dwarven cleric that likes to poke at said paladin, an NG human fighter who is part of the local militia and thinks that the entire party is nuts and also likes to poke at the paladin, and a half-elven ranger that is really wondering about the group he's just joined, make for a very interesting and RP intensive game.

Anyway, back on track, I also enjoy RttToEE greatly as a GM, none of the others have really interested me enough to get.

 

[Skade]

I agree. For dungeoncrawl, RttoEE is a great module. For more roleplaying, Witchfire Trilogy is excellent.

third vote for the Witchfire Trilogy. I loved this series so much I have actually run it twice for different groups. You really should read all three before running them, and probably tweak the NPC design to suit your needs, but the story and gameplay is fantastic.

 

[Bricktop]

By far, The Temple of the Grand Fenge by Dungeon Download. I mean, for a cheap PDF, you just can't beat it!

 

[yennico]

It depends on if you ask me as player or as DM

As a player, I only played the WotC Adventure path modules (till Iron fortess..).

From all adventure path modules I played the best adventure
IMHO as player is: Speakers of the dreams
IMHO as DM it would be Nightfang spire, because I really love the two golems and the scrying device. This is evil, but as player I would hate that

I and my players hate dungeon adventures, dungeon crawls or hack ´n slash adventures.
I love adventures of intrigues.
So far I only own some non-WotC adventures, but most of them also are dungeon crawls in some kind

Just my 2 cents
yennico

 

[Bulak]

My personal favorite is Green Ronin's Death in Freeport, followed very closely by the rest of the trilogy.

 

[JoeGKushner]

With a few more adventures out, has anyone changed their minds or thought of anything else that they liked?

I tend to like bigger adventures that take place in cities like the Grey Citadel or the Banewarrens or series that are closely tied together like the Witchfire trilogy or the original Freeport one.

 

[SpiderMonkey]

Gotta be Death in Freeport for me. Sunless Citadel as a close second for a weird and misplaced nostalgia factor: for some reason, it reminds me of the castle ruins/dungeon presented in the dm's section of the old basic red boxed set.