Besides the standard request of wanting a print magazine over a digital one (but would not mind a print magazine with digital extras) I would prefer a magazine that covers more than just 4e. Articles for older editions would be great, as would articles for other game systems. Actually, if they did an adventure once in awhile for older editions, that would be a good motivation for getting it.
I really want stuff I can use. Short adventures, sort of sidetrack adventures. Nothing elaborate, just some nice diversions. Also some NPCs with an interesting background (just not tied to any one setting). I like the idea of tokens for all the creatures in an adventure, that would be great. Oh, and while we are at it, some interesting maps, both marked and unmarked, to use in making my own adventures.