I'll offer up a somewhat dissenting alternative - if painting miniatures is your hobby, you shouldn't charge anything.
If it's your hobby, you'd be painting something anyway, right? If the person you paint for pays for the miniature itself, the other costs (paints and time) are things you'd spend anyhow.
This person is giving you a chance to do something you enjoy more cheaply than you'd normally would, as you'd usually have to pay for the mini out of your own pocket. He's giving you something, and you're gonna make him pay to do it?
So expecting Free is foolish.
Who gets to keep the mini...?
Dude, the post you are responding to is from 2003. I'm pretty sure that the statute of limitations is up after seventeen years.
And, I didn't say anyone should expect anything. I was putting the focus on a choice by the individual painter. No expectations on the part of others logically follows or is implied.
I know i'm late to the party here, but the fella that said he would gladly paint a mini, for anyone, ive got 200 whats your address. I need them painted and I want them done by the end of the week ... K thanks
Also when you are done I plan on purchasing 600 more from a kickstarter, will you also paint those for free?
I have a few friends that need free painting done as well, not sure how many minis they have but shoot me an email and we can get it setup!
This is the simple answer. The price will vary a lot based on your skill level.The simple answer is, "What the market will bear."