D&D General What's your view on a pirate-driven campaign?

[Paul Farquhar]

Really surprised to see no mentions of One Piece

I have seen at least one reference earlier in this thread.

 

[Kestrel]

I have seen at least one reference earlier in this thread.

Found it!

 

[GrimCo]

Really surprised to see no mentions of One Piece. Luffy's crew are essentially all Chaotic Good and help anyone they consider their friends. The setting has a tyrannical world government which places Luffy's crew at odds with the government for wanting to be free.

As I watch the anime more (I'm around ep 100), it looks more and more like D&D, with over the top powers and many excursions away from the ship, fighting in what could be dungeons. Been thinking about a pirate themed game myself based on the show.

Cause One Piece uses pirates as aesthetic mostly. Yes, it looks like D&D cause it's fantasy adventure with pirate visuals.

 

[Olgar Shiverstone]

Depends on the kind of pirate.

Ninja pirates? Perhaps.

Robot ninja pirates? Closer.

Robot ninja dinosaur pirates? I'm in.

 

[Warpiglet-7]

Years ago while my wife and I were poor and in grad school, we co-played the windwaker
In the Zelda series. She was the brains, I was the reflexes!

Anyway, the joy of landing on a new island was genuine. It hard to explain the wonder I sometimes felt.

If you could bottle that feeling of “wow! What is this place?!” It would be a winner.

You could focus on self contained mini adventures on weird islands. And then back on ship!

I would focus less on stabbing defenseless crews of other ships and more on exploration and privateer D&D adventuring/treasure seeking and hunting.

Who knows what might happen? Paid to hunt a sea monster? Rescuing stranded lords? Being mercenaries fighting in island to island war?

Limitless. And what I love is u can have some things somewhat self contained yet give players the he option of what to go to next!

I think I have my next campaign in mind…

 

[Kestrel]

Cause One Piece uses pirates as aesthetic mostly. Yes, it looks like D&D cause it's fantasy adventure with pirate visuals.

Yup! That would be a great game. Warpiglet-7's post above is One Piece's plot once they hit the Grand Line, although they don't seek treasure so much (Nami being the exception).

 

[Warpiglet-7]

Yup! That would be a great game. Warpiglet-7's post above is One Piece's plot once they hit the Grand Line, although they don't seek treasure so much (Nami being the exception).

I did not connect that. Watched a number of episodes of one piece with my kid! But no idea where in the series…or if they were actually contiguous. That show is nuts!

 

[Whizbang Dustyboots]

Cause One Piece uses pirates as aesthetic mostly. Yes, it looks like D&D cause it's fantasy adventure with pirate visuals.

To be fair, that's most pirate RPG games generally. Even Pirate Borg has a lot of dungeon ruin-crawling,

 

[Kestrel]

I did not connect that. Watched a number of episodes of one piece with my kid! But no idea where in the series…or if they were actually contiguous. That show is nuts!

Yeah, once they hit the Grand Line, it is island hopping with separate adventures and plots. You described some of them without even knowing it! There is a contiguous plot behind it all but each island is different stories.