AD&D 2E Which 2e campaign setting should make a comeback in 4e?

[Aloïsius]

Dark sun, of course ! I think it's the more "4e" of the old setting (point of light, heroes start at third level, heroes are less dependant of magic item ...)

 

[HeavenShallBurn]

Not on the list, but Mystara!

I *loved* Mystara and all the gazetteers! They started doing Mystara for 2nd Edition, but didn't get very far. It'd be awesome to see that setting again.

^
|
Points at what he said. I'd really like to see Mystara back, I've missed it ever since 1e. And I'd love to see it get the high production quality/great art treatment of a modern first-rate hardcover.

 

[A'koss]

Without question, Planescape is the setting I'd like to see make a return more than any of the others. I've always had a soft spot for Dark Sun, but I've always felt it was more of a "one trick pony" setting and generally used it as a place for the PCs to visit, not to stay. Same can be said about Ravenloft & Oriental Adventures. Spelljammer is only D&D setting I openly despise, I'd be sanguine to see any of the others produced...

 

[Gundark]

first choice would be Mystara. But since that's not on the poll I picked birthright.

 

[Mouseferatu]

I can't believe I'm the only person who voted for Al-Qadim.

That said, it was a very tough choice. (The only reason I didn't vote Ravenloft is that it is coming back, as a fiction line. Between new fiction and all the old RPG material, I think it's set for a while. I still want it back, but the need isn't as immediate.)

I could also just as easily welcome Dark Sun back with open arms.

 

[resistor]

I voted for Planescape, because it's my favorite, but I'd really like to see any of them come back. I don't have the time/money to invest in acquiring the old materials (I started playing around the time of 3e), and I'd love to have to chance to experience them all.

 

[TwinBahamut]

I would prefer to see a completely new setting, rather than an old one, but I suppose if it had to be an old one, Oriental Adventures is always good. It adds needed setting variety.

I am also interested in Birthright. The premise behind it seems fascinating. However, I have no first-hand experience with the setting, so I couldn't really vote for it...

 

[Angel Tarragon]

Betcha can't click just one? Birthright, for me

Nope. If it would have been multiple choice I'd have gone for: Al-Qadim, Dark Sun, Planescape, Ravenloft & Spelljammer.

So I'll abstain.

 

[Belorin]

Spelljammer for me, I miss my newly refitted Scorpion ship.

 

[Plane Sailing]

I'd have to say Birthright, because it is such a different setting for PC adventures (i.e. the more political line of adventuring) and it is the area which has possible seen the least love - didn't it come about in the tail end of TSRs days?