Which d20 witch is...

[Kichwas]

the one to go with?

Mongoose Quintessential Witch
Green Ronin's Witch's Handbook
AEG's Magic (which has a witch class)


Any preferences and reasons thereof?

 

[Crothian]

I like the one in Magic. Mainly because it's the oinly one I have, but it does the job I need. I don't need a full book devoted to the witch. With Magic I get everything I need plus rules for other magic types.

 

[JoeGKushner]

You're missing the Witch from The Hunt and the witch from Way of the Witch from Citizen Games.

So far I think GR's from the Witch's Handbook covers it best. Never liked witches that could cast fireballs and prismatic sprays. The Hunt would be up there too but the Q. Witch has a lot of other goods to it while the Hunt is mainly a functional core class.

 

[Piratecat]

Arcady, welcome back! I was just thinking that I hadn't seen you in ages.

 

[Tsyr]

I prefer the witch from Mongoose' "Slaine", myself.

 

[Kevin O'Reilly]

My own , but thanks for asking

However, the Slaine Witch is nice

 

[Buttercup]

Green Ronin's witch is my favorite. I agree that fireballs don't seem in keeping with the stereotipical witch.

And welcome back from me too! I've been wondering about where you had gotten to.

(edit-can't spell!)

 

[Nightfall]

Nice to see you my old foe, erhm I mean Friend!

Btw I can't say but I think either Mongoose or Green Ronin's. (Since they both did great Shamans. )

 

[Voadam]

I Shocked that Nightfall is not plugging the blood witch from R&R I.

 

[Kichwas]

Presently I have AEG's Magic and the Green Ronin Witch book, with the Mongoose book on order.

I like the feel of the Green Ronin Witch, but the spell list is too small and leaves me wondering what to do about other d20 sources.

I like the AEG Witch but doubt I would get the on the fly magic past my DM. As well I don't like that the class has no 'features' as it levels. I like to see 'features' in a class list even if they don't really do much as they make you feel you're getting something for staying in.

I hope to have the Mongoose book in a day or so.


I've never seen the 'Slaine' book up close. Saw it in the store and put it in the category of "setting or module" which is my 'don't usually buy' list.