Which Logo set do you like??

[Michael Morris]

A side by side comparison with poll

 

[Panthanas]

Ooooo! I got to vote first!
Hooray for me!

 

[Gez]

I don't expect much vote for the old theme... Maybe Diaglo?

 

[Michael Morris]

Heh heh, who knows.. Oh, almost forgot one - Polls... Didn't recall it until I posted a poll

 

[Skade]

Well, so far everyone agrees. The new ones rock.

 

[ergeheilalt]

I like the new ones a whole lot more than the old ones. Great Job Michael.

I only have 3 that I'm not truely enthralled with ...
The D&D buttons are a bit full and hard to read - especially, when all that matters (IMO) is the edition number. The last problem I can see now, is how incredebly small the FR logo is. I had to think about it before I realized what it was... maybe you could do the button is a similar fashion as you did the Arcana Unearthed button.

Overall, these buttons you have suggested seem to me much better than the bright, gawdy buttons we have now.

My 2 cents,
Erge

 

[Michael Morris]

I like the new ones a whole lot more than the old ones. Great Job Michael.

I only have 3 that I'm not truely enthralled with ...
The D&D buttons are a bit full and hard to read - especially, when all that matters (IMO) is the edition number. The last problem I can see now, is how incredebly small the FR logo is. I had to think about it before I realized what it was... maybe you could do the button is a similar fashion as you did the Arcana Unearthed button.

Overall, these buttons you have suggested seem to me much better than the bright, gawdy buttons we have now.

My 2 cents,
Erge

I think the FR logo will be fine despite the size, once you realize what it is it's easy to spot it from then on. I may have to change it anyway as Russ has always been wary of using trademarked images on the site in any way (same thing applies to the 3.0 & 3.5 logos).

 

[Michael Morris]

Here's a touch up to the 3.0 & 3.5 logos to make them more distinct

 

[Magius del Cotto]

Personally, I feel that it's better to use a simple (but effective) solution as opposed to a more complex one. IMO, the old ones, while not as pretty as the new ones, are easier to handle. They take up less space, and aren't graphically complex. However, that's just my opinion, and by the looks of things, it's not one shared by everyone else.
Good job on them, Morris. Just not the sort of thing I'd like to look at when I come to a board like this one.
Magius out.

 

[Gnarlo]

Anyone else feel like they've wandered into ENWorld v3.5? Changes for the sake of changes?

The new icons are very pretty, but the old icons are very clear and easy to read on a scan down the subject list. They may be bright and gawdy, but I don't have to spend several seconds figuring out what the heck they say.