D&D (2024) Which Setting Featured Already in 5E Do You Want a New Supplement For?

[Stormonu]

I was torn between grabbing WotC and making them redo Spelljammer "correctly", but I think that's a lost cause.

I think I'd rather see more Dragonlance in the War of the Lance era, either a campaign setting or another adventure taking place in yet another place on Ansalon during the war. Written with a strong guiding hand from the Hickman's.

(What I really, really want is Doomspace walked back and they actually give us Dark Sun, but never going to happen now).

 

[cbwjm]

This was difficult, I'd love more planescape, but also more dragonlance. Ultimately dragonlance won out, but still, it was a difficult decision for me.

 

[Levistus's_Leviathan]

I would love an adventure compilation book for Eberron, similar to the Saltmarsh/Candlekeep/Radiant Citadel line of books. Low level noir adventures in Sharn, mid-level pulp adventures in Xen’drik, and high-level Doom-esque adventures in Khyber and the planes.

 

[Tonguez]

i'

 

[aco175]

I'd be ok with another default Forgotten Realms (FR) book. It seems to have been a while since something decent came out. Shattered Obelisk felt like it was going to be good but could have been based in any world but they just threw Phandalin on it. Golden Vault could have been a generic series, along with Candlekeep. Icewind Dale was solid FR stuff. A new Red Wizards book that is not just a reprint of 5e playtest with Dragonspear castle might be good.

Actually I could use an updated 5e playtest book with the Daggerford stuff and Dragonspear castle. That would make a good campaign for my group.

 

[DEFCON 1]

My current campaign is Theros, so I'd take some material for that. I've already gone through a lot of the DMs Guild stuff, so anything new from WotC would be lovely.

 

[Burnside]

I'd like to see a hardcover campaign adventure set in Eberron. I'm not sure if that qualifies as a "supplement."

 

[Parmandur]

I'd like a return to Eberron in the slipcase format. Book one would be a mechanical tune-up for things like dragonmarks, species options, and the Artificer; maybe a revisit to Stormreach to bring in the history of the new mini-giant Goliaths. Book two would be a Eberron monster guide. Book three would be a big juicy adventure.

Oh, yeah, a Xen'drik Campain Setting & Adventure slipcase would be excellent.

I think Eberron could make excellent use out of the new tech on hand for Level 1 Feats and Backgrounds. Dragonmarks would be well-served as Level 1 Feats.

How about Construct-only Backgrounds that give Warforged stuff like Mithiril bodies or other alternative body configurations?

 

[Parmandur]

I was torn between grabbing WotC and making them redo Spelljammer "correctly", but I think that's a lost cause.

I think I'd rather see more Dragonlance in the War of the Lance era, either a campaign setting or another adventure taking place in yet another place on Ansalon during the war. Written with a strong guiding hand from the Hickman's.

(What I really, really want is Doomspace walked back and they actually give us Dark Sun, but never going to happen now).

I'd like to see the DL series adapted head-on.

 

[DEFCON 1]

If there are any Eberron fans who have not yet picked up any of the 3.5 Eberron supplements, those are fantastic and 99% edition agnostic. Five Nations, Dragonmarked, Sharn: City of Towers, and all the rest are all worthwhile purchases and will have hundreds the times the amount of useful material for an Eberron campaign than any new book WotC might release under the '5E' banner.

Don't wait for WotC to reprint or make up new things, go pick up the original material. You'll be happy you did.