Worst D&D products ever.

[MrFilthyIke]

I liked Maztica, but had no use for it. :\

My worst? The Complete Priests is one. But I liked most of my books, even broken ones. I loves my presciouses...

 

[Timely Drought]

The Great Modron March

That adventure featured the worst rail-roading of the PCs at the beginning. Abysmally weak scenario design.

 

[weezoh]

Gotta agree with the Complete Priest's Handbook and my own nomination is Return to Undermountain

 

[(Psi)SeveredHead]

2e's psionics - Complete Guide to Psionics (or whatever it was called) and the Way of the Psionicist. Ruined the reputation of psionics for a long time.

Complete Warrior. (I thought Complete Divine stunk too, but that was a matter of degree and the amnesia when it came to 3.5 improvements - otherwise it wasn't worse than any other unbalanced splatbook.)

Can I nominate an Alternity product? I've only seen one bad Alternity product, and unfortunately it was the one I had the most hope for - StarCraft Alternity.

 

[Sir Elton]

Weak huh?

The Slayer's Guide to Amazons

The Wand of Archeal

Everquack Player's Handbook

(Ironically, I gave it a good review on RPG.net. But after reading through it a second time, I changed my opinion. It's useless . . . Except for EverQuack Roleplaying Games).

 

[Jeff Wilder]

Every Second Edition Complete book published. They drove me away from D&D for years.

 

[Evilhalfling]

I really enjoyed the complete priests handbook -
I spent hours making terribly wealk customized clerics, and wondering why no one would play them. A cleric without healing is playable, right?

My homebrew prolly would have been better off without it.

Others I actually hated
complete elves
complete Psionics
immortals set
exalted Deeds
complete wizards
- spelljammer modual with a huge beholder ship - what were they/I thinking?
most of the 3.0 splats - exepting tome and blood(the only one I own)

To defend the Creature Catalog (SSS) yeah most of the monsters sucked,
but each has a reason for existing, it has a comprehensiveness not managed by core worlds. As a design philsophy it was great. Plus the fact that it beat the 3.0 MM to the gameshops by a weekend that still makes me chuckle.

 

[Sado]

Am I the only one who liked the Hero Builder's Guide? True, there was nothing ground-breaking, but it was a fun read. I enjoyed it.

But what is up with that outfit the guy on the cover is wearing? He looks like a guy in drag who had his cocktail dress ripped half off.

 

[Crothian]

Am I the only one who liked the Hero Builder's Guide? True, there was nothing ground-breaking, but it was a fun read. I enjoyed it.

Not the only one, thr gnome section inspired my gnome society.

 

[Sado]

Not the only one, thr gnome section inspired my gnome society.

It's where I got the idea for my half-orc wizard. He was the servant-slave of a powerful summoner, and he snuck down to the library and read her spellbooks at night after she was asleep. He had to flee when she found out about it.