D&D 5E Would You Allow These Feats?

[Paul Farquhar]

If the player is confidant RPing it out and makes a good arguement I'll grant advantage.

If they're not confident they can roll dice.

Table preference. At my table they either negotiate or pay full price, and you asked if I would allow it.

 

[Li Shenron]

Divine soul needs a new feat. Feat two the PCs are becoming traders as a "domain". They were rewarded with an estate and have bought a sandship.


1.
+1 charisma
You know one extra spell (warlock, sorcerer, bard)

2.
+1 charisma
Opposed persuade vs wisdom (insight). Buy or sell one item +/- 10%

They are both quite underwhelming...

I would avoid the +1 Charisma, and give a bigger number of known extra spells, for example 3 of them. Or maybe 4 if taken from the same school of magic.

I am not even sure the second idea needs a feat, it could be just a general house rule for negotiating a better price. Generally speaking, I am really not a fan of character abilities (feats or whatever) that can directly result in a net monetary gain.

 

[Krachek]

I think a feat deserve a more distinctive feature,
why not a spell from any class like magical secret?

 

[jgsugden]

I think a feat deserve a more distinctive feature,
why not a spell from any class like magical secret?

That can be quite powerful as not all spells are create equal. Some are class features in spell clothing.