Summer-Knight925
First Post
Look, I'm not in the mood to edition war (and by your tone I'm assuming that's what you're looking for, if not prove me wrong.) so I'm just going to walk away from this conversation. But you have fun.
I tried that once too, it still started an edition war.
But the healing potions...they were (usually) made by spellcasters, the usually being of course A. finding them in a dungeon (in which we can assume they were made by a spellcaster) or B. some odd fountain that is best not talked about.
Another loop hole in this entire thread, it was what you DISLIKE/LIKE about them, not what they were like in older editions, I read through 21 pages of "but X was like Y and now X is like P"
does it matter?
If you don't have fun with a game, don't play it. I use to fight in the edition war, and then I realized it isn't worth it because there are other games then D&D.