The VOIDRUNNER'S CODEX is coming! Explore new worlds, fight oppressive empires, fend off fearsome aliens, and wield deadly psionics with this comprehensive boxed set expansion for 5E and A5E!
Well, DaveMage's comment was not truly a threadcrap, but an honest opinion. Now, if Dave argues the point with the intention of arguing for arguing sake, that's different. I think he just wanted to say he wished he felt the old excitement.
Amen! :)
To add my own beginning into the mix, I started with a BECMI/1E hybrid with no miniatures. After experiencing D&D with miniatures, and a lengthy stint playing Battletech, I was converted to loving my minis and enjoying their use in gaming. :)
These threads are argumentative because everything is subject to interpretation. There are parts that explicity imply the use of minis, and in the very same book parts that tell you they are optional. I think the books themselves lead to this continuous arguement.
edit: As a side note, most...
Even when not using minis, every group I have been in still used counters or markers or some sort and maps. The most abstract games still had tactical encounters. I do feel that OD&D, AD&D, and 3E all assume miniature use as a core part of the D&D.
But then again, we are all expressing...
I plan on using it for source information, but the adventures are based off the Gold Box game and it shows. I was mostly curious if there were any I might have missed.