FrogReaver
As long as i get to be the frog
I definitely do. You don't seem to understand how limited a resource it is, or how absurdly, uselessly, white room the idea of using SD on nothing else is.
You can't use it all the time. You can't rely on it to make most attacks with the -5+10.
At least 1/4, possibly more, of your attacks in most adventuring days will be made without knowing the exact AC of the enemy. You will misspend some of your superiority dice, or you will decline to use it when you ought to, at least a few times per adventure. Even if you don't, you don't have enough SD, and the player who is going to only ever use their SD for Precision Attack is going to be too rare to consider in a discussion of how playing a build will work out at the table.
Get out of the white room, and sit at a table with this.
I have used the build in a campaign. I assure you it works exactly as described. You have so many uses of it and need to use it so rarely that you rarely run out of superiority dice.
You do occasionally misspend dice or don't have any idea what the ac of an enemy is and avoid using it. That said the tactic at level 5 with 2 attacks is closer to +3.5 for all attacks over the whole day when not misused. I estimate +3 for all attacks over the whole day because I agree and understand you will misuse it sometimes.
Last edited: