Pathfinder 1E [OOC] Pathfinder: Jade Regent

[perrinmiller]

I'm good with everything curative being in the communal stash.

I would amend that to Curative and Utility if a consensus agrees.
For example those Cloaks of Resistance +1 are good for a long time. We can pass them around from person to person until no one wants it and we would rather have the gold value instead.

The thing about magical items is that they are essentially always worth half value, yet worth way more than their weight in gold. There is no reason to liquidate them immediately until someone needs/wants to buy something and we are short on gold.

 

[jkason]

Catching up after extended holiday / work backlog. I have no objections to the strategies folks are putting forth.

 

[Guest 11456]

These are the items that could be sold (not including magic items).
Each player please vote on whether you wish to sell {S} or keep {K} each line.
That way I can easily determine how much gold you are getting.
For the group to sell any items the vote must be unanimously (S).
If an item contains multiple and you wish to keep part of it then vote like this:
{4 {S}; 1 {K}} Cobblepots (5)

Items:
Flask of Alchemist Fire
Flask of Alchemist Fire
Flask of Acid
Tanglefoot Bag
Smokestick
Tindertwig
Tindertwig
Tindertwig
Caltrops
Caltrops
Caltrops
Small MW Chain Shirt
Small Chain Shirt
Small Chain Shirt
Small Studded Leather
Small Leather Armor
Small MW Short Sword
Small MW Short Sword
Small Short Sword
Small Club
Small MW Composite Bow
Small Shortbow
Small Hand Crossbow
Small Arrow (16)
Small Crossbow Bolt (9)
Small MW Spear
Small Javelin
Thieves' Tools
Formula Book
Grappling Hook
20' of Rope
Small Silver Mirror
Fireworks I (2)
Fireworks II (5)
Small Poor Leather Armor (25)
Small Poor Light Wooden Shield (25)
Small Poor Short Sword (24)
Chest
MW Shuriken (6)
Long Hairpin w/ Red Pearl
Gold & Ivory Fan

 

[Guest 11456]

These are the magic items that could be sold.
Each player please vote on whether you wish to sell {S} or keep {K} each line.
That way I can easily determine how much gold you are getting.
For the group to sell any items the vote must be unanimously (S).
If an item contains multiples and you wish to keep part of it then vote like this:
{4 {S}; 1 {K}} Cobblepots (5)

Potion of CLW (6)
Wand of CLW
Wand
Ring
Cloak
Cloak of Resistance
Small Arrows +1 (4)
Small Arrows (7)

 

[Shayuri]

The only thing Sachiko is really REALLY keen on keeping are the relics from Tian; the pin and the fan. She likes her cloak too though, and would keep that unless the pressure of peers made her capitulate.

Oh, and she wants the thieve's tools.

Other that that, she's fine with selling anything the party as a whole doesn't want (like the healing potions and so on).

She might be interested in the fireworks too, if someone reminds her of them...but it might be best if she never got her hands on those.

 

[Binder Fred]

Fastus'd like to keep the flask of acid (you can do some nice etching on metal with those things), the red chest + "broaches" (AKA shurikens), because they're nice souvenirs -- but if somebody else wants them, no big... He's tried to give the silver mirror to Elsbeth some times back, but I don't know if she took it or not.

Oh, and he'll take a cloak of resistance. That might look cool. His dad could probably use the "poor quality" stuff to remelt and make into other things too.

Let's put the fireworks in the communal bin, although he can carry them if you guys want? That might come at some risk, of course.

In other words: [sblock=Items]Flask of Alchemist Fire
Flask of Alchemist Fire
{Fa} Flask of Acid
Tanglefoot Bag
Smokestick
Tindertwig
Tindertwig
Tindertwig
Caltrops
Caltrops
Caltrops
Small MW Chain Shirt
Small Chain Shirt
Small Chain Shirt
Small Studded Leather
Small Leather Armor
Small MW Short Sword
Small MW Short Sword
Small Short Sword
Small Club
Small MW Composite Bow
Small Shortbow
Small Hand Crossbow
Small Arrow (16)
Small Crossbow Bolt (9)
Small MW Spear
Small Javelin
{Sa} Thieves' Tools
Formula Book
Grappling Hook
20' of Rope
{El} Small Silver Mirror
{Party} Fireworks I (2)
{Party} Fireworks II (5)
Small Poor Leather Armor (25)
Small Poor Light Wooden Shield (25)
Small Poor Short Sword (24)
{Fa} Chest
{Fa} MW Shuriken (6)
{Sa} Long Hairpin w/ Red Pearl
{Sa} Gold & Ivory Fan

Magical items:
{Party} Potion of CLW (6)
{Party} Wand of CLW
{Party} Wand
{Party} Ring
{Party} Cloak
{Fa} Cloak of Resistance
Small Arrows +1 (4)
Small Arrows (7)[/sblock]

 

[Graybeard]

Here is what Elsbeth will suggest:
She would like the 2 flasks of Alchemist Fire and the mirror for herself. Suggest selling the small weapons and armor unless Fastus can do something with them.

Items:
Flask of Alchemist Fire. Keep
Flask of Alchemist Fire. Keep
Flask of Acid. K
Tanglefoot Bag. K
Smokestick. K
Tindertwig. K
Tindertwi . K
Tindertwig. K
Caltrops. K
Caltrops. K
Caltrops. K
Small MW Chain Shirt. S
Small Chain Shirt. S
Small Chain Shirt S
Small Studded Leather. S
Small Leather Armor. S
Small MW Short Sword. S
Small MW Short Sword. S
Small Short Sword S
Small Club. S
Small MW Composite Bow. S
Small Shortbow S
Small Hand Crossbow. S
Small Arrow (16). S
Small Crossbow Bolt (9). S
Small MW Spear. S
Small Javelin. S
Thieves' Tools
Formula Book. S. (Unless someone can use it)
Grappling Hook. K
20' of Rope. K
Small Silver Mirror. Keep
Fireworks I (2). K
Fireworks II (5). K
Small Poor Leather Armor (25). S
Small Poor Light Wooden Shield (25). S
Small Poor Short Sword (24). S
Chest. K
MW Shuriken (6). K
Long Hairpin w/ Red Pearl. K
Gold & Ivory Fan[/QUOTE]. K

 

[Graybeard]

Potion of CLW (6). K. (Party use)
Wand of CLW. K (if someone in the party can use it)
Wand. K (Elsbeth may claim it later after it is identified)
Rin . K
Cloak. K
Cloak of Resistance. K
Small Arrows +1 (4). S
Small Arrows (7). S

 

[Kaodi]

After a great deal of minimal amount of soul searching on the reasonableness of taking into account future midgets in our midst I have come to conclusion that we should sell all of the mundane equipment sized for small characters and keep everything else.

 

[perrinmiller]

TS, IIRC we decided that we should only keep magic things and healing items as community property.

Giving up my share of treasure for people to keep the mundane gear for their personal use or whims was not what was agreed to during previous discussions. If someone wants to keep something like the Alchemist’s Fire, Acid flasks, etc…, that should come from their share of the treasure.

It is being “sold”, but to a PC so they in effect get it at half price.

Any item we want to keep as party property should require a majority agreement to be exempt from being part of the split up treasure.

So looking at the lists:
Sell everything non-magical, either to merchants or PCs who claim as their split of the treasure.

Jariah is already holding the Acid Flask and that is primarily what she wants out of the mundane gear because it can be used as a focus for Acid Splash and increases the damage by 1. That would cost her its value from her share of the gold.

What is the value of the fireworks and the mechanical stats? I consider them to be an item like Acid flasks and Alchemist’s Fire, basically weapons for personal use.

Magical items:
{K} Potion of CLW (6) -> 1 Each
{K} Wand of CLW -> Elsbeth (she can use it)
{K} Wand -> ??
{K} Ring -> ??
{K} Cloak -> ??
{K} Cloak of Resistance -> Sachiko or Fastus

The healing items can be distributed to who can use them best. But we have 3-4 magic items to distribute amongst us. No everyone is going to get a magic item. But until we know what the other three are, it is hard to say who should have what for the party’s benefit.