• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

December Rules Update Available


log in or register to remove this ad

arcane riposte is still useless because it lacks an implement property as well as a proficient bonus...

to make it even worthwhile to use it has to be int +4 or even int +6 vs AC and increase by +2 at epic...

and the targeted assault is no fix as it reads in the update document... (marking you was replayed by that has you marked... the problem was that it read marked by you in the primal power handbook)
 

Update said:
The purpose of careful attack is to increase a character’s chance to hit. However, twin strike was always a better choice because it representeed equivalent damage and better accuracy. This change makes careful attack a viable choice.
No, not vs. twin strike it doesn't. Careful Attack only barely edges out twin strike in a very small percentage of the attacks (at needing an 18-20 to hit). Otherwise, twin strike is always better. Only now, careful attack is always better than a basic attack, except that you can get basic-only improvements.
 

For very low damage bonus values, Careful Attack is actually looking an awful lot better than it was. Wonder if I still have that spreadsheet for comparing the two hanging around, hmm.
 

Yep, found it. At static bonus 0, it gives the nod to Careful for when you need a 16-21 with Twin Strike. At static bonus 2, it's 17-21. At 6, it's 18-21. If I bump things up to 12 static, d12 base damage die, 2d8 quarry, +7 Dex, I still end up with 18-21.

So that's a _much_ better situation than it used to be, even if I still wouldn't bother :)
 



I think the Healer Sash got overdone... it went from a device for between-turn healing or allowing a leaderless group to adapt to something I wouldn't expect people to actually wear. Better safe than sorry, though, I guess.
 


I'm very happy with these updates.

I had a houserule exactly as the Careful Attack fix.
But also applied to Sure Strike. Oh well.
 

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top