thedungeondelver
Adventurer
Hey, my last trip to the FLGS, 100% of the RPGs being played were AD&D 1e. 
That aside, with regard to this I'm tempted to say I wish the reprint was 3rd edition. I have no rules preference for that version of the game but I think 3rd edition was so monumental that it has a special significance. It was a clean break with the past, and yet at the same time embraced what the authors thought were the most important elements of the past (WORLD OF GREYHAWK, the "back to the dungeon!" mindset).
It was just a real landmark on the D&D landscape. It was the first edition under a wholly new company. It was the first edition to include computer software with it, it was the first edition to do away with the D&D rules almost entirely...
So if this is true, again, I'd be tempted to say they should have reprinted 3rd edition, if for no other reason that historical purposes.

That aside, with regard to this I'm tempted to say I wish the reprint was 3rd edition. I have no rules preference for that version of the game but I think 3rd edition was so monumental that it has a special significance. It was a clean break with the past, and yet at the same time embraced what the authors thought were the most important elements of the past (WORLD OF GREYHAWK, the "back to the dungeon!" mindset).
It was just a real landmark on the D&D landscape. It was the first edition under a wholly new company. It was the first edition to include computer software with it, it was the first edition to do away with the D&D rules almost entirely...
So if this is true, again, I'd be tempted to say they should have reprinted 3rd edition, if for no other reason that historical purposes.