I can see Umbran's point, that a few seemed to miss so that they could make a shot or two of their own. Here is how I read it, from someone who has no actual investment in the argument.
The thread has devolved into people on either side attacking, not the play style of fudging or not, but the actual people on the other side. While no one has specifically said "badwrongfun" there have been many similar statement thrown around.
I believe that the most level headed statement was made a few pages back, saying that this is NOT an argument between good and evil. Fudging v. Not fudging is simply a matter of Lawful or Chaotic, and should be treated as such. It should be assumed by all that we are of Good alignment, because we all want what is best for everyone at the table, or as many people as is possible, where "best" means the most possible fun. Now we just need to figure out how to reconcile Chaotic and Lawful.
Lastly, before anyone gets defensive on instinct, you do NOT need to defend yourself to me. I am a random guy on the forum, and did nothing to deserve an explanation from you about your play style, or whether or not you fit with what I have said. If you feel you are not included in my statement, assume that I was not talking to you, and was instead talking about everyone else in the thread.
The thread has devolved into people on either side attacking, not the play style of fudging or not, but the actual people on the other side. While no one has specifically said "badwrongfun" there have been many similar statement thrown around.
I believe that the most level headed statement was made a few pages back, saying that this is NOT an argument between good and evil. Fudging v. Not fudging is simply a matter of Lawful or Chaotic, and should be treated as such. It should be assumed by all that we are of Good alignment, because we all want what is best for everyone at the table, or as many people as is possible, where "best" means the most possible fun. Now we just need to figure out how to reconcile Chaotic and Lawful.
Lastly, before anyone gets defensive on instinct, you do NOT need to defend yourself to me. I am a random guy on the forum, and did nothing to deserve an explanation from you about your play style, or whether or not you fit with what I have said. If you feel you are not included in my statement, assume that I was not talking to you, and was instead talking about everyone else in the thread.