iserith
Magic Wordsmith
That would be fine.
But in [MENTION=97077]iserith[/MENTION] world it seems you can't do this: your character has to go along with the plan and take that action even if in-character it otherwise wouldn't.
A character "would" do what the player says it does. There is not some outside force determining what a character "would" do such that what the player has it do contradicts said outside force. This is all in your head.
When it comes to in-character discussions e.g. planning how to storm the castle, player and character should be exactly the same. In other words if you say it at the table, your character says it in the game.
"Should?" Careful now. Not everyone thinks that way and nowhere it is written that this must be so.
And yes, stubborn people sometimes play stubborn characters. Non-stubborn people also sometimes play stubborn characters.
That said, you mention Roll20 which tells me you're gaming online rather than in person - a whole different thing. I only ever play in-person games.
Lanefan
I game both online and in person. It's really not so different. I just don't have to smell anyone else's farts but my own.