X13Phantom
Explorer
If the GM says it is a troll then they are the ones metagaming, because the statement means they think the players should know what the creature is.
I’m sorry, that isn’t an objective statement it’s your opinion. In my experience a level of maturity is required to be able to separate what you know from what you should know. Particularly when projecting into a character.I mean, we can agree there’s no point arguing further, but that’s the best you’ll get. It objectively has nothing to do with maturity.
I’m sorry, that isn’t an objective statement it’s your opinion. In my experience a level of maturity is required to be able to separate what you know from what you should know. Particularly when projecting into a character.
Please note I said maturity not age. Age has nothing to do with it.
There’s no issue with preference. People can choose to roleplay as they like.It's odd to see preference equated to maturity...
There’s no issue with preference. People can choose to roleplay as they like.
I’m saying being able to separate what you can do from what you should do is a sign of maturity. Being unable to restrain yourself is a sign of immaturity.
A mature player may still choose to play or not to play the strict player knowledge/character knowledge divide. They will have a choice. That would be a question of preference and I have no issue with that. They can make that decision though because they are mature.
I need only to have met people who are immature and perfectly capable and willing to separate player and character knowledge, and the reverse, to objectively prove that it isn’t a matter of maturity.I’m sorry, that isn’t an objective statement it’s your opinion. In my experience a level of maturity is required to be able to separate what you know from what you should know. Particularly when projecting into a character.
Please note I said maturity not age. Age has nothing to do with it.
I made a direct observation. I must have missed the rule that said I'm required to answer your question.