It's more like:
Person 1: "Really? 4 years? Last year we had an adventure that is filled with darkness and all sorts of really, really grim stuff. How are depictions of child murder 'too soft, sleek and silly'?"
Person 2: No, it's all nothing but fluffy bunnies and cutesy displacer beasts on covers!
Person 1: Really? There's no displacer beast on the cover of my Witchlight copy. Maybe it's different from yours? There is an image of a cute displacer beast inside the book. True. But, then again, there's all sort of really dark and grim stuff there too.
Person 2: NO It's all fluffy bunnies!
Person 1: okay?