WotC D&D Historian Ben Riggs says the OGL fiasco was Chris Cocks idea.

So you would prefer politicians you wouldn't want to be near
no, but it also really does not make a difference for who I would vote for. There are absolutely politicians I could see having a beer with as being fun and would never vote for, and ones I would think having a beer with would be boring but vote for. It’s simply an irrelevant criteria
 

log in or register to remove this ad


The MBA is a bare necessity for getting the gig: having design experience is not. So it is, indeed, compelling to see that fairly rare combo at WotC now.
That's only true if A) that design experience is relevant, which it isn't (since video game design is dissimilar from tabletop RPG design), and B) that the two of them somehow endow the person with greater capabilities than either one alone (which as noted is a special pleading on your part).
As to examples: Warren Spector, Zeb Cook, Lawrence Schick, Jeff Grubb, Paul Reich III, just off the top of my head and I know there are more if I thought about it for a second.
Which are examples of tabletop RPG designers moving into video games, not video game designers moving into tabletop. Again, even assuming that these are representative of those two necessarily synergizing (which isn't axiomatic, since it ignores the stories of people who've tried to make this transition and failed), you can't say that because A leads to B, that means that B leads to A. Or at least, not without demonstrating how and why that's so.
Read any text book on how design works, I won'tdo your homework for you:
Again, Hitchens's razor cuts this argument down. If you can't meet the burden of proof when you make an assertion, then your assertion can be dismissed. Saying "I'm right, go look it up" means that you're ceding the argument.
the process is indeed transferable between industries, so a designer executive is an interesting development.
See above. You haven't established that it is, and your examples don't speak to the type of transfer we're talking about with regard to Hight (video games to TTRPGs) compared to the other people you cited (who are TTRPGs to video games).
I said that I was not counting those in the first post, you close read is flatly incorrect and bizarre.
Again, looking at your post, you said "not even counting" rather than "not counting." Those two terms are not identical, with the former meaning that you're noting something in addition to what you are counting, just that they're supplementary. The only bizarre thing is that you'd try to say otherwise.
Most people at WotC work at a videongame studio, making video games. That makes it a video game company. And that isn't going to change trajectory, frankly.
No, it doesn't. As noted before, it makes WotC a company that wants to transfer into being video games. Whether or not they succeed remains an open question, though their track record on this remains uninspiring.
 


That's just it. There's nothing there either way. He's either going to do well, do poorly, or possibly even be practically invisible to the majority of people.

I agree, we won't know for a while. Even then, odds are we still probably won't know because as much influence as he may carry going forward it's still a massive bureaucracy with a lot of moving parts.
 


no, but it also really does not make a difference for who I would vote for. There are absolutely politicians I could see having a beer with as being fun and would never vote for, and ones I would think having a beer with would be boring but vote for. It’s simply an irrelevant criteria
Yet on the ground, it usually does make a difference to most people, and that is not a bad instinct to be ignored.
 

Again, looking at your post, you said "not even counting" rather than "not counting." Those two terms are not identical, with the former meaning that you're noting something in addition to what you are counting, just that they're supplementary. The only bizarre thing is that you'd try to say otherwise.
That is ridiculous, I said specifically that I was not counting those.
 

That is ridiculous, I said specifically that I was not counting those.
Again, that's not what you said. When someone says "they have five of something, not even counting all of these others," then you're treating "all of these others" as a supplement to those aforementioned five.
 

there are several, off the top of my head Matt Colville has done both for several years each

Zeb Cook, Lawrence Schick, Dennis Detwiller, Jennell Jaquays...it's definitely not a small list. I would say it seems pretty common and I would say that after years of low pay in the TTRPG space, it's a better financial move that allows them to creatively play in the same space.
 

Remove ads

Top