Bedrockgames
I post in the voice of Christopher Walken
Not a fan of Calvin and Hobbes, then? Cartoons can contain much truth.
I don't. Comic strips as a medium were never really that big for me (I didn't like comics or graphic novels either which is why I am not a huge super hero movie fan). We got the funny times and I would read some of those, but stuff like Calvin and Hobbes was not my cup of tea (nothing against it, I just never got into it)
While we can talk about the presentation of arguments about individual works, those discussions do not enlighten us on "the industry" as a whole. The point about the entire genre narrowing from a publishing standpoint is a different kind of question, one that we should, at least in theory, be able to measure, rather than rely on feelings.
Do you care to be more clear about what you think "the industry" is, what it means for it to "narrow", and what your basis for the impression might be?
To me, the industry isn't narrowing if works of various outlooks are still making it to the public - books get published, visual media makes it to screens, and so on. Critics and social media responses are not "the industry".
So, as I said - Correia and his like are still getting published, alongside authors with quite differing viewpoints. How is that "narrowing"?
@The Firebird answered much of this but I would add that it is pretty obvious when you look at the kinds of things publishers were asking for submissions on. And the kinds of public conversations publishers were having. That doesn't mean there weren't exceptions. But it has also been much bigger than publishing. People can examine this and decide for themselves. I am not super concerned about convincing them this is all true. It is in my view blindingly obvious though.
I was just trying to make the point that the critique leveled initially by Correia had some merit and reflected something that was occurring across the arts. Most of the arts have been affected by this. At the same time I don't think it is as important now as it was two or three years ago, since there is clearly a weakening of the PC clamp I had mentioned. My bigger concern is really the pendulum swinging the other way (like I said earlier I find some of the reactions to this stuff to be just as stifling, and in many cases worse). I don't like puritans from either camp.