Recent content by AdmundfortGeographer

I can understand that. But Draw Steel’s power roll mechanic just fits you into 1 of 3 tiered results by basically a table lookup. So a roll of 3 on 2d10 but with double edge just grants the middle tier result which normally requires a 12-16. Practically getting +10 bonus for pitiful dice roll...

Yeah, getting the framework that a 1st level; Draw Steel characters are possibly closer to a 5th level character in D&D. I’d recommend strongly The Delian Tomb. $10 for a full started set experience, including such that the start of the adventure literally has the Director narrate like a video...

This does seem to be an underreported expectation. That the combat maps should be interesting and filled a bunch with believable utility. Our group has had years of Gloomhaven/Frosthaven play and scenarios with few-to-none objects/traps/hazardous terrain are fine but quite a few characters in...

My group has much more gotten the feel of the combat and we vibe with it. My table’s players are really getting into the tactics of position for flanking or high ground or pushing into objects/walls/foes/vertically. It has taken a couple sessions but the group has found the grove where Draw...

I’ve favored the Dalelands too. But when I’m running there I include the Moonsea and Dragon Reach, with Sembia hugging the coast and little interior. My vision however is stuck in the gray box presentation with the Moonsea city states much closer rivals jockeying for favorable position in the...

A very important thing about the possible Hamanu redemption in Lynn Abbey’s final book is that it was also read from Hamanu’s perspective, a very unreliable narrator of themselves. Anyone is bound to put their own story in a flattering light, especially someone like that. But Lynn had zero...

I may be misremembering, but I though that it was not explicit the Blue Age halfling ancestors used themselves as raw material to create the new species, or if the new species were life-shaped out of the ocean material everything else that was life-shaped.

Directors are given flexibility for adjudicating advantageous reasons. High ground is already noted in the rules as one though. To get wonky in the math: Roles are 2d10, you get one of three results. One advantage is called an Edge, it is +2 on that role. Two advantages (double Edge) bumps the...

It was also to mathematically sorta balance the equipment rules that had weaker materials that did less damage and broke. Most seemed to ignore the fragile material rules though.

If I recall, Dragon Kings and The Valley of Dust and Fire were both written before Troy wrote the finale novel in the Prism Pentad. After Troy was shuffled off to novels, the novel writers of TSR were highly separated from the RPG developers.

I am as well. I even never liked the expanded regional map because in my mind it radically broke with what The Wanderer’s Journal said was beyond the Tablelands. Though I gladly selectively imported back material from the Revised era to my personal expanded Tablelands.

You agreed to the site terms. That includes taking disagreement with moderation to private message, or getting punted from the thread.

Category error. There are no good and no bad people involved.

I had criticisms there. For instance the first encounter lists Malice on the 1st encounter sheet. I thought that means I get to use it! Maybe? Because in the 2nd encounter it unlocks Malice as a thing the director gets to use so beware. Huh. Whoopsie? The players asked if there could be an...

I’m the current dm for our group and we had started a new campaign using 2024 5E, and just completed getting an adventure and got to level 3. About to start the next adventure and The Delian Tomb had been in my downloads for a couple weeks. I heard a ton of word of mouth that it can be basically...