Recent content by gban007

I think this highlights issue with DMG in general, that it sort of serves two purposes: 1. a guide to DMing which by its nature is best suited for people new to the system or even role playing in general ( and here i feel that even moving from 1e to 5e is basically still same system for an...

Just finished second book, and will read third shortly. Yes was a bit of a step down, as didnt have the inter weaving thread showing the world, but still built well on the prior book I thought in showing how a Fifth Season impacts on the world, along with continuing to show both the bleakness...

No, I'm saying I dont see the problem with rulesets putting more guidance in, or even explicit rules binding on the DM. I already said in my post (albeit not the most well formatted) that I dont expect it to address the problem with bad DMs, as you say, they will ignore it anyway. But if may...

Not really no sorry. Maybe for burning wheel it is quite explicit, and hss no rooms for house rules, and so the system is very much take it as is or leave it ( which i dont necessarily see as a problem, to me is a bit like some video games are customisable and moddable, others arent ). But for...

Almost all rpg rules limit what a GM can do, whether things like how many hp a PC has before can be taken down, how spells cast by or against DM controlled characters etc work, how AC works, how classes, subclasses, levels etc work. But a GM can then house rule any of those if they want. I...

Bit of an update on some books read ? (Not going well on keeping things updated, my goodreads updates have been poor this year, maybe only 20% of books read). Finished the Fifth Season, a strong book that has led to me already starting the next one. Quite a bleak world/ cultures, especially...

Possibly also depends on circumstances. With my current role playing group where we've been playing on and off together for 20 plus years across various systems and winnowed out the couple of people who didn't suit the overall group (one as a player, the other as both player and DM) we tend to...

Feels to me if can't use prior work as inspiration, then presumably a new moral rpg would not have: Classes Levels 6 attributes A percentile roll under type system A d20 resolution system A 2d20 or 2d6 resolution system Advantage/ disadvantage Feats Metacurrencies And a whole list more. And I...

I guess from my perspective, if you don't care what Micah said, why did you jump in on a response to Micah? As it stands by choosing to only read the one line response without without the context of what it was replying to, is why you thought it was attacking a preference when I dont think...

Just started reading the Fifth Season by N.K.Jemison, been on my to read list for a while but also found out been mixing it up with A Memory Called Empire, so another one I'll have to read at some point too.

I think mainly suggesting near systems (e.g. for DnD, A5E or lord of the rings 5e or ToV) that may address the issue, some rules supplement that may address it (like Up in Arms addresses some issues for WFRP 4e), or even complete other systems that may meet overall needs better, say Dragonbane...

But isn't there circular logic at some point here? 'I think this rule is an issue, and ideally should be changed' 'It isn't a problem as can be house ruled away, dnd is flexible so rule doesn't beef changing' 'My DM won't allow us to house rule that' 'That is DnD, the DM has the power per the...

Like only certain classes can wear certain Armour, rather than allowing a mage to be in full plate even if with some sort of trade off.

I enjoy dnd, and the type of games you look to like to play, so dont get me wrong, but ones we've tended to accept in past that look to just be for genre or narrative sort of purposes (or perhaps game balance, but hard to determine sometimes): Hard Armour limits (and even dnd novels allowed this...

@JiffyPopTart my attempt to reply to your message didnt go well, so tagging you instead sorry. For this example to hold true, I think we would need to see other foes in the movie also shot in lethal location but not killed. There were other foes he had to work harder for, due to not being able...