TSR Running list of potential problematic issues in TSR era DnD

Status
Not open for further replies.
Additionally, I am no stranger to racism as there was quite a bit of antisemitism against me growing up.
Yeah and of course antisemitic tropes can end up being used similarly (i.e. a negatively-portrayed fantasy/SF race just happens to align with a bunch of them), but I think as a result of education about Nazi Germany, their propaganda, and the Holocaust, there's a lot more awareness in US society (and perhaps Western society in general) as to what antisemitic tropes look like as compared to ones that typically target other ethnic groups.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

jasper

Rotten DM
Here are two quick examples that illustrate my comment above. Two pieces I recently had commissioned. Both were diverse artists I had hired. One is an artist of Mesoamerican heritage, doing a piece inspired from their culture. The other is from an African American, but his dress is wholly European. I should have caught that and did better.

rs=w:1280


rs=w:1280
If this is not a 1E commision. You have cheesecake in the second pic. And every one is white.
 


jasper

Rotten DM
Bad Editing. Information scattered over the PHB and DMG. System Shock Survival rolls anyone.
Same Spell different result.
Bad Math. Fireball size.
% in lair or was liar
Roll high, no roll low, and which die are we using.

OP " Drop Nipples in chain mail bikinis" because "Excessive cheesecake or topless women everywhere." the second covers the first.
 

Weiley31

Legend
Man I cannot tell you how much I love cheesecake. It is so good and I can't imagine life without it. Growing up it was something to look forward to when it happened. And when cheesecake happened, it did. So good.

Last time I had some good cheesecake was about, six weeks ago IIRC? The Italian takeout place I ordered from had cheesecake on the menu and my mom was like "well order it then." The only bad thing about cheesecake is that it is rich and I don't really want my arteries to get clogged. Also a lot of places will make it pricey and only give you like a sliver/small piece. The cheesecake at Walmart isn't too bad either.

Now that I think back about it, the Cinderella cheesecakes were absolutely overrated and wasn't as epic as a lot of people made it out to be during the 90's growing up.
 




billd91

Not your screen monkey (he/him)
There is an issue with this? really? I mean Christianity, Islam, Judaism, Atenism, even some "pagan" religions are monotheistic. Is it no longer acceptable to be a monotheistic?
It's not a question of believing in a monotheistic deity. It's about living in a pantheist society where the gods have different portfolios they control. You're generally not going to worship just one - you're going to participate in the other festivals, feast days, holy days of the others too because other parts of your society are governed by those other gods.

Nothing wrong with that - the modern analogy is there being a whole league of teams and yet you only cheer for one.

EDIT to add: and the reason a cleric only worships one deity is because that's the deity who provides her with her spells every day!

As a cleric, you may be initiated into the organization of one and are learning its secrets and specific rituals, but still show up to worship or at least propitiate the others. You've got a patron, but the other gods are still reflected in the society around you and require your worshipful attention from time to time when it's appropriate. You may be a priest of St Cuthbert and have duties around his churches and flock, but you still celebrate Wenta the Alewife at the harvest fest and when the new, magnificently carved doors are installed at your church, you're still going to have the priest of Dalt, the god of doors and portals, come by to properly bless them.
 

Snarf Zagyg

Notorious Liquefactionist
@Sacrosanct

Advice: You might get more light than heat if you re-start the thread and do the following...

1. Designate it a "+" thread.

2. Make an explicit note that you design OSR products, and you want to make sure they are inclusive.

3. Request specific input as to common pitfalls that TSR-era products had.

I know that you did this, with your disclaimers, but by making it a "+" thread and just having one specific, bolded, disclaimer at the beginning (something like, "This is just for feedback to design inclusive old school emulations ... if you don't have something positive to add, please respect the "+" tag and do not participate.") you might have a more productive conversation?
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Remove ads

Top