Search results

I was loyal to Gygax for 9 years before I quit him... Mearls has had his run. /mearlsquit

And I expected you to question Luddites being on the internet in the first place... -- evil "Cyber Ludditte Ugg of Clan Ggu" eeyore

GNS HERESY! BURN THE WITCH! I agree with you but don't tell anyone, I've got a rep to look out for.

There is a thread still in the top 50 views on the D&D and Pathfinder subforum! /pagequit

PREACH IT FROM THE CAVE BROTHER! INTERNET LUDDITES UNITE! -- evil "Ugg of Clan Ggu" eeyore Stop trying to oppress our temporal ethnicity!

So you're counting the Paladin Alignment Argument Thread as a joke!?!?! /LGquit!

Sound reasoning. Side question: Did the PCs listen at any doors before just trying to open them? If not, that might be something to mention to them. Either directly (if you discuss this encounter and what lead to it blossoming into a near TPK), as an aside the next time the party opens a...

How about compromise guys? Ogress and Beefcake? No? /quitrage

My earlier response should have been more nuanced, To Railroad or Not To Railroad is not nearly so binary as I presented it. bill has done a good job of representing some the grey areas between those two stark positions.

I have been drug into yet another mindless Alignment debate! :mad: / :rant:

He's an excellent example in all ways aside from that one time he shtupped the Queen. Technically by any D&D standards* all he needs to do is atone and seek penance with the proper Clerical benefactor and "poof" he's a Paladin again. Don't know why he was ever stated as anything other... oh...

Fun ain't it? You say my position is an error, I say your's is illogical (and an error). Round and round. You'll not convince me that Paladins have to be anything other than what they were originally, 12 peerless warriors and the boon companions of Roland. Seriously, anyone claiming...

Bah, he doesn't matter anymore. :P

Established setting is being reset. As happens when rules are changed. Likely many of those Gods that had individual "holy warriors" will now have Oath Bound Paladins serving them.

Skullkickers is righteous! Although... issue 6 "The Cleavin Part" which was done by guest artist, writer, and letterer is my favorite. Oooooohhhhh.... it went to online! No wonder I can't find it in print anymore.

That's my take. On a side note, I just noticed that the playtest Monk also has no alignment restrictions. I'm doing my happy dance. Why not? Everytime I run a new campaign (even if it's the "same" world) I change a few fundimental things just to spice it up. People who get their panties in...

I fourth the "let them get captured". It's a heavy-handed tactic when it's railroaded on them, but this "worked perfectly" during organic play. Also, I'd take a few seconds and talk to the players before the next game. Lat them know what happened (ie they tripped two encounters instead of...

Your position across the last ten pages has been: "Paladins can only be LG. Anyone who thinks otherwise for any reason is wrong." Well, I have to say, your position is wrong. I can very easily take the current 5e playtest Paladin and make it exclusively LG complaint. Step 1- Add the...

No. Forcing them to play through it is though. "Railroad" is a term that gets a bad wrap. It boils down to this, if your players are making train sounds and comments like "Hey, a station, we hope the line stops here long enough for us step out and stretch our legs"... then you are "doing it...

Didn't vote in the poll then? Good luck getting that in 6e. :)