Search results

  1. atanakar

    D&D 5E (2014) [5e] Are classes too generic? (Read the OP before answering)

    They will have the chance to give their input, but I find it's best to arrive with a canvas so we can talk around a common ground and make modifications if need be. I don't do free form creativity.
  2. atanakar

    D&D General The Generic Deities of D&D

    I do the same. The players worship their local pantheon at temples. A statues for each god in the same building. In my current campaign the temples are circular with alcoves on the perimeter. There are no masses and large ceremonies inside the temples. These are done outside during festivals and...
  3. atanakar

    D&D 5E (2014) [5e] Are classes too generic? (Read the OP before answering)

    I do have players lined up. I wouldn't spend energy on this if I didn't, to preserve what is left of my sanity!
  4. atanakar

    D&D General My Favorite Edition of D&D is...

    My parents made me eat generic industrial mustard during my childhood. I love it, until I tried Dijon mustard. I have no love or nostalgia for industrial mustard. 🙃
  5. atanakar

    D&D General My Favorite Edition of D&D is...

    My favorite edition is 5e. Not because it is the current one but because it is very flexible thanks to the DMG options. But I long for simpler decluttered classes as in Holmes and B/X. I can't resolve myself to play these old editions because there are many things I am glad to have left behind...
  6. atanakar

    D&D 5E (2014) [5e] Are classes too generic? (Read the OP before answering)

    Because I don't like how they are written and what they do. Been there, done that too many times since 1981.
  7. atanakar

    D&D 5E (2014) [5e] Are classes too generic? (Read the OP before answering)

    It didn't start like that last night but it is becoming that. I'm really like it when the system (characters) and the setting match perfectly. 5e lets me do that. I've done so much campaigns (world building) since 1981. I need to create something entirely new if I want to continue playing D&D.
  8. atanakar

    D&D 5E (2014) [5e] Are classes too generic? (Read the OP before answering)

    I came to the same conclusion. Ban all other classes and build 4 classes just for the campaign setting. That is what I'm working on today: Shaman (dreamland focus, tailored spell list) Guardian (ranger-warlord mix) Warrior (fighter-protector mix) Beastkin (monk-half-beast mix) No sub-classes...
  9. atanakar

    D&D 5E (2014) [5e] Are classes too generic? (Read the OP before answering)

    Some very good suggestions by some of you. Thank you! Keep em coming. ;)
  10. atanakar

    D&D 5E (2014) [5e] Are classes too generic? (Read the OP before answering)

    I'm thinking of a Witch/Shaman class that can use a mix of arcane and divine spells. I don't what the player to do that using multi-classing. I prefer making a class from the ground up. I might have been reading to many old Dragon Magazines lately... :)
  11. atanakar

    D&D 5E (2014) [5e] Are classes too generic? (Read the OP before answering)

    I have a very good campaign idea but looking at the class list (including 3rd level archetypes) I find that none of them would fit the concept. Don't get me wrong D&D classes are great and they work well within a certain style of play that I've enjoyed a lot over the decades. But this time I...
  12. atanakar

    D&D 5E (2014) Survivor 5e Plants - Shambling mound composts the competition!

    Assassin Vine 27 Awakened Shrub 22 Awakened Tree 24 Corpse Flower 20 Kelpie 19 Myconid Adult 22 Myconid Sovereign 21 Myconid Sprout 18 Needle Blight 14 Needle Lord 23 Needle Spawn 20 Shambling Mound 26+1 = 27 Shrieker 23 Thorn Slinger 20 Treant 26 Tree Blight 18 Tri-flower Frond 18 Vegepygmy...
  13. atanakar

    OD&D Edition Experience: Did/Do You Play OD&D? How Was/Is It?

    Just rolled up 4 classic characters (F,C,M-U,T) using Bleu Holmes Journeyman rules. I intend to run a solitaire game (no DM) with a randomly generated dungeon. A few changes: - Ability scores get modern modifiers - HPs: d10 F, d8 C, d6 T, d4 M-U. Max HPs + Const modifier - Thief skills start...
  14. atanakar

    D&D 5E (2014) Survivor 5e Plants - Shambling mound composts the competition!

    Assassin Vine 27 Awakened Shrub 22 Awakened Tree 23 Corpse Flower 20 Kelpie 21 Myconid Adult 21 Myconid Sovereign 21 Myconid Sprout 20 Needle Blight 16 Needle Lord 22 Needle Spawn 20 Quaggoth Spore Servant 4 Shambling Mound 28+1 = 29 Shrieker 22 Thorn Slinger 20 Treant 26 Tree Blight 18...
  15. atanakar

    D&D 5E (2014) Percentage Chart?

    D6. One variant would be to have a conflict between two of them (roll d6 twice) and let the player decide which side he will take and thus choose his companion.
  16. atanakar

    D&D 5E (2014) Percentage Chart?

    No Roll. Let him observe or interact with each NPC in a tavern. The player decides which one he wants as sidekick.
  17. atanakar

    AD&D 2E Edition Experience - Did/Do you Play AD&D 2E? How Was/Is It?

    That is true. Despite the fact that I home brewed my campaigns buying these books was very inspirational for me.
  18. atanakar

    D&D General [History] How heavy armors and long swords were used in the 15th century

    Found this very interesting video created by the Cluny Museum of Medieval History (France). Quite an eye opener. It is only 3.5 minutes. Well worth watching:
Top