Search results

Wild shaping is one of the much trickier set of choices to make a character work well. It very much depends on what forms your DM lets you use, and whether the setting is suitable for making good use of it (outdoors is better, vs. tight dungeon spaces which may restrict you to a medium or small...

Providing you can hit multiple opponents, spells like Moonbeam, Call Lightning, and Conjure Animals are more effective in combat than just wild shaping. Moonbeam and Call Lightning both require an action to activate each turn, so there's no benefit to being wild shaped in such cases. Conjure...

I have been playing an A5E Druid with the Skinchanger archetype, essentially the equivalent of the 5E Circle of the Moon. In my opinion, there are a couple of things that the A5E Druid does really well to make being wild shaped more useful: you can talk; and you can cast range self or touch...

I have been planning to get an Elven Chain Shirt made for my Imp familiar to boost their AC from 13 to 16. No proficiency required, which is the only way that works. :)

Yes, I assume so. There's no specific rules added for additional exertion points that Fighter or Psyknight get that specifies that they're only recovered on a long rest. That does make sense regarding their exertion pool. Divorce it from the spell slots. It is still good, as they get a whole...

A possible problem here is the assumption that 1 spell slot level = 2 exertion points. This works at lower levels, but at high levels it means either that they have too few spell slots if you use exertion instead, or they end up with too much exertion - if they were to channel all those spell...

The proposal that I made along these lines avoids buffing Herald. But it is more fiddly, as the exertion cost for spell slots does change as Herald levels up.

Another approach that I would be tempted to adopt is moving all spell casters to a short rest refresh mechanic, and for half-casters like Herald this can equate to an 2x proficiency bonus per short rest exertion mechanic if you fudge the numbers appropriately: For spell levels 1 through 5, you...

That doesn't work, unfortunately. With the approach that you're suggesting, when they level dip into Fighter, they still get the additional proficiency bonus exertion points (i.e., 2x proficiency bonus in total), which has a similar problem to before, just not as bad. You have to give the...

It should be a short rest, if you don't want Herald/Fighter-dip issues. I am wondering if it makes sense to have the efficiency of conversion from exertion to spell slots vary with Herald level. Something like this initially: Instead of spell slots, Herald gets 2x proficiency bonus exertion...

The way we play it is as follows: If you have Darkvision, you can see stuff within that radius. If you don't have Darkvision, you need a light source, else you are effectively blinded. The difference vs. the rules as written is that we are not applying the disadvantage on Wisdom (Perception)...

Another one, probably playing it this way by mistake ... In darkness, within Darkvision range typically 60', no disadvantage on Wisdom (Perception) vision checks, and skipping the -5 penalty on passive Perception. I am sure this is a mistake by the rules-as-written, but I don't recall our DMs...

There are plenty of things that were ghastly about 1E. Level drain. Imbalance between classes, including poor implementation of multi-classing. Non-Human level limits. Random rolling for ability scores and hit points leading to imbalance, players wanting to repeatedly reroll ability scores, etc...

Yes. If the exertion points from the Fighter dip are lower, it is much more reasonable.

My main point with the suggestion to switch Herald over to a purely exertion point mechanic was to avoid them getting a bunch of exertion points with a level dip into Fighter. If Herald still gets spell slots, it doesn't solve that problem.

The value of Dangerous Strikes depends heavily on your build. If you're stacking a bunch of extra non-dice damage modifiers, it's effectiveness can also depend on whether your virtual table top system supports it. Specifically, Fantasy Grounds does not do so out of the box, only doubling dice...

Correct. I missed that the exertion points are 2x spell slot level. Sorry about that. I will correct my post. When we're playing, we do use our short rests, both to recover HP and for PCs such as martial types and Warlock to recover their class abilities on a short rest. Less of an issue for...

If you have a level in Fighter, you get 2x proficiency bonus exertion points per short rest. Comparing vs. a level 8 Herald, a level 9 Herald does have two extra 3rd level spell slots, the equivalent of 2x 2x 3 = 12 exertion points per long rest. Given 2 short rests per long rest, that's the...

Given that you can make a ranged attack roll with disadvantage against an invisible creature or if you are blinded, it doesn't seem too unreasonable to permit it under certain circumstances. First, you need to know which 5'x5' square the target is in (assuming medium size), or a good guess as to...

How often are you casting Protection from Evil and Good? How often are you fighting aberrations, celestials, elementals, fey, fiends, and undead, or needing to avoid charm, frighten, or possession? In those circumstances, yes, it is a good spell. But while I've had access to that spell with...