D&D 5E (2024) 5.5 Fighter Best Eince 2E

[Gladius Legis]

Not like this one. No other ability in the game is so out of bounds as the 2024 indomitable. No other ability is even close.

War Cleric got +10 to hit with an attack at level 2. And at level 6 could give that +10 to any other ally instead. That's more out of bounds much earlier in the game.

I don't think it is appropriate for a feature to allow a 17th level fighter to reroll a failed save with a +17 three times a day.

Really? At the same level Wizards are casting Wish and Meteor Swarm or turning into adult dragons, and Clerics are healing the whole party hundreds of hit points? But the Fighter auto-succeeding on some of its saves 3/day is the issue?

(And not even auto-succeeding on all saves, there's plenty of monsters you could fight at level 17 that have DCs for abilities in the 20s, and even 2024 Indomitable at that level won't guarantee success if it's on a save in which the Fighter has an 8 stat and no save proficiency.)

Looks to me like you just hate Fighters getting nice things at all.

 

[Gladius Legis]

Fighters (and Monks) not so much.

Well now we see the problem. Your sense of what is strong and what is not is rather off base. Monks were almost universally regarded as the weakest class in 2014.