D&D 5E A tweak for the Battlemaster fighter

[dave2008]

Except of course, that everyone who thinks they are disputing my point is actually proving it. You have to use Action Surge for an attack to equalise matters. That's a bit of a problem when there are so many other uses for Action Surge.

The ranger and paladin have so many other uses for their spells slots (and you know - I have actually seen those used for other things than Hunter's mark and smites). What it your point. Why are you so afraid of action surge damage?

 

[dave2008]

And I have repeatedly addressed them. The sources of the Bonus Attack and Reaction attack are irrelevant. A red herring. Duelling is just one style; the maths applies to all styles. Run the numbers yourself.

We have run the numbers and they indicated you were wrong. We have even shown them to you several times. That is why we are asking for your specific build that creates the results you are describing.

 

[Paul Farquhar]

Non-combat uses of Action Surge:

Walking and chewing gum at the same time;
.
.
.