Darklone said:
D&D often features close range melee archers... IMC, these didn't occur too often (I prefer a little bit more realistic battles). The standard melee tank who has a bow also is either in melee or not
Well, originally I was imagining a scenario where the fighter is using a bow, and his target is in melee with one of his allies, not that the fighter himself would be in melee while using the bow.

In such a circumstance, the fighter (without Precise Shot) would suck up a -4 to hit, because his target is in melee with an ally.
But then it occured to me that if the target can or should be engaged in melee by the party, the fighter would be the one doing it. The only time a fighter is going to use his bow in the first place is when the target can't be engaged in melee for whatever reason. So no need for Precise Shot.
Inconsequenti-AL said:
that's very similar to what I had in my last homebrew. Had a thread about it ages ago and someone (pretty sure it was Buttercup?) came up with an idea that got called 'Borrowers' - Bigun and Littleun couples - mostly aranged halfling/human marriges - that couldn't breed, so tended to adopt half-X children. Group were suprised to find a proud halfling mother and her 4 half orc children
Consider this yoinked. I love it. It's a wonderfully rich addition to the core concept.
Half Dwarves are great - always liked them - ever since I saw the Mul from Dark Sun. I can imagine a spiked chain wielder left a lasting impression and perhaps a few scars?
Definitely. Creating guys like him is one of the fun parts of DMing. I didn't feel bad when he was eventually cut down. The looks on the players' faces when I first introduced him was worth it.
And a little side question: You can use light weapons in a grapple... wonder if that includes the Sunblade?
Oh my... I don't know where to even begin looking in the rules for clarification on that one, though my gut tells me "no", unfortunately. It can be wielded like a shortsword, but it's still as long as a bastard sword. I wouldn't hold it against you if you tried to slip it by your DM, though.
