• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

Another "Have You Ever Had This Player?" Discussion

Zweihänder

First Post
I'm starting to think there should be a section just for these...

Anyway, I should preempt this by saying I observed these events from a player's perspective, not a DM's, so perhaps I found this all the more irritating because of it.

Our Group was as follows (so I can refer to people by name):

~Tak Battlehammer (Paladin) (me)
~Jasmine (Sorcerer/Rogue)
~Aeril Talengoren (Sorcerer)
~Keira (Cleric)
~Mr. Odz and Mr. Enz (Wizards)

We were proceeding along a forest trail, when we hear a pained roar coming from the woods to our left. We investigate, and discover a small, wounded Deinonychus being savaged by a pair of Velociraptors. I insist that we assist it, and the rest of the party quickly agree. I hit the high Init, and whang one of them but good. Keira goes next, and does the same. Mr. Odz and Mr. Enz go next, and conjure up some illusory celestial dire badgers to distract the raptors. Then it's Aeril's turn. He uses Scorching Ray on one of them, reducing it to single-digit HP. Jasmine comes up, turns towards Aeril, and fires an arrow at him. After she rolls and misses, she claims she "purposefully missed". She says it was "supposed to be a warning." When we inquire as to what she was warning against, she says, "don't use magic on them. That's evil." Now, let's examine this a bit.

She's a [size=huge][bold]SORCERER[/bold][/size].

I whang her but good with my fist, obviously doing subdual damage, and tell her never to attack a party member through lethal force ever again. Beating someone about the head to bring them to their senses is one thing, but risking their death is something else entirely.

This is not the first time she has purposefully distanced herself from the group. After the session, I mention to her that her character is an absolute bitch. She responds, "No she's not... she's just interesting..."

Correct me if I'm wrong, but being randomly offended at things and purposefully distancing yourself from the rest of the party does not make one interesting, does it?

Has anyone else had such an experience?
 

log in or register to remove this ad


Zweihänder said:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but being randomly offended at things and purposefully distancing yourself from the rest of the party does not make one interesting, does it?

Has anyone else had such an experience?

Hi Zweihänder,

there is always the chance you are gaming with someone who wants to be in the spotlight of the groups attention. Believe it or not, the longer this habit is ignored by the other players, the more drastical the ways of drawing attention will become. Take a look at an older thread i had on such a player here. Maybe if you should shove her forwards into the leading role every now and then things will become better again?

Dougal
 


Dougal DeKree said:
Maybe if you should shove her forwards into the leading role every now and then things will become better again?

I wouldn't give her the satisfaction. I'll tolerate my friends' characters "acting out" here and there within reason. If she's a sorcerer commanding the others not to use magic, that's just. . .well. . .stupid. Talk to her about it, and if she continues attacking the other characters, I'd allow the others to go ahead and kill her.
 


Darmanicus said:
Kill her and loot the body, now that's interesting! :cool:

Yep, that might be what it takes to break the habit (along with the blatant reference to her 'interesting' line), but keep in mind that this can result in hurt feelings, etc, etc.

I suggest you discuss this with some of the other members of your group- does it bother them as well? If so, you should try a group discussion with her- let her know this kind of thing doesn't fly. If you have to, give her the boot- but give her a chance to change first.
 


the Jester said:
I suggest you discuss this with some of the other members of your group- does it bother them as well? If so, you should try a group discussion with her- let her know this kind of thing doesn't fly. If you have to, give her the boot- but give her a chance to change first.

and you can even do this in character.

esp the PC she shot at.

boot her PC from the party instead of killing her. more of a lawful thing for a paladin to do anyway.
 


Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top