D&D 5E Anyone using spell points from the DMG?

[vivsavage]

I'm curious as to how well they worked for you, especially at higher levels. BONUS: what do you think of – instead of spell slots or spell points – using a spellcasting roll to see if a spell works or not?

 

[Bolares]

I've always wanted to try them.... but in the end my players weren't interested in the extra bit of math.

I think they give you more flexibility, but may change the balance of encounters if the players jus send 5th level spell after 5th level spell all day.

 

[Savage Wombat]

I use it for sorcerers only, and it seems to be popular with players - but I've never had a game with both a wizard and a sorcerer for direct comparison of play experience.

I think it's a bit more powerful, but I haven't found it game-breaking.

 

[Bolares]

I use it for sorcerers only,

OOOH, that's a neat idea!

 

[Bolares]

How does the math of converting sorc points to spell points behave?

 

[Yaarel]

Regarding the math of the spell points, defacto, there is no "gap" between slot 2 and slot 3. There are some very powerful level 2 spells and some very subpar slot 3 spells. Thus there is a seemless continuum from 1 to 5.

Recalculate the spell points available according to the following values

Slot 1: 2 points
Slot 2: 3 points
Slot 3: 4 points
Slot 4: 5 points
Slot 5: 6 points

The higher slots are treated separately.

I actually only use points for slots 1 to 5. For slots 6 to 9, the game system treats them separately, and I just use the regular per-day slots for them. This also avoids spamming the spells of slots 6 to 9.

A character can spend 1 point to cast an unknown/unprepared cantrip.

 

[Weiley31]

Whatever you do, don't ever use it for the Warlock. According to the DMG, the Universe will legit imploded if done.

And then your Patron's credit card get declined when they go to Red Lobster for dinner.

 

[Oofta]

Whatever you do, don't ever use it for the Warlock. According to the DMG, the Universe will legit imploded if done.

And then your Patron's credit card get declined when they go to Red Lobster for dinner.

That's a bad thing because ... why?

 

[Weiley31]

That's a bad thing because ... why?

Cuz then your Warlock doesn't get any of those delicious cheese bisquit things they have.

 

[Shiroiken]

I've always wanted to try them.... but in the end my players weren't interested in the extra bit of math.

I think they give you more flexibility, but may change the balance of encounters if the players jus send 5th level spell after 5th level spell all day.

The big issue is using it outside of the 6-8 encounters per day. This lets a character "nova" every combat, since they just don't care about low level spells. With extended encounters, they will have to fall back on cantrips much quicker if they do this.