Levistus's_Leviathan
5e Freelancer
Yes. Every time I ask them to roll, I ask if they're proficient and what their bonus is. End of story. It's not hard, it's not much more work than not doing that (and it's well worth the effort, in my experience). So nothing else you say matters.Do you really do this? Every time? Really?
If their stats make it impossible, they can't do it, and therefore can't even roll. Period. The end.