Riley McClean
Riley quickly shifts his aim to the next rustler in the group along the river, and sends two .56 caliber slugs his way.
Riley shoots at #16, who should still be flat footed.
First shot To hit: 10+10-2 for range(Far Shot)=18,
Darkness concealment=37
Damage=5+8=13,
Edit: forgot to confirm the critical assuming they are flatfooted: 4+10-2=12
Damage x2
Second shot To Hit=10+5-2=13.
Darkness concealment=27,
Damage=1+8=9,
Confirm critical if a hit=10+5-2=13
Damage x2