• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

Can an AoO provoke an AoO?

Ristamar said:
Right, to use the feats it has to be melee weapons, though to simply use two-weapon fighting, they don't have to...

Ok ... btw to avoid confusion just write 'fighting with two weapons' (or FwTW) instead of two-weapon fighting (TWF), which nearly always means the feat.
 

log in or register to remove this ad


I think some of the confusion comes from the idea of "weilding" a weapon. I don't know what the official take on this is, but from my experience weilding for most characters has meant a weapon that either 1) you attack with, or 2) Kept ready to use for AOO.

In that fashion, if a character with a longsword and a light mace charged into a character, he could say "I'm not weildling the mace" in which case he doesn't assume two-weapon penalties. However, any AOO he got to make would have to be with his longsword.

If you applied this argument to the bow scenario, then while fireing your bow you could say that your weilding your fist. This would cause TWF penalties, but would allow you to have a threatened range. Or you could drop the bow, which automatically means your weilding your fists. However, on the next round, you could choose not to weild your bow. You could keep it in one hand, and suffer no TWF penalties with your fist, but then you could not fire the bow that round.

Just to note, if your using that system that are also other drawbacks to not weilding a weapon. I would also say that disarming that weapon would be automatic, or at least a big bonus, because your not activively working with it.
 

drnuncheon said:
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Ristamar
If someone knows if both weapons have to be melee weapons for the bonuses to apply, please let speak up, but I believe this is correct.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



According to the core rules, either or both can be ranged. I believe the Sage decided to alter this in one of his rulings to say that the 2WF feat is only intended for melee use - possibly to forestall 2wf + Rapid Shot combos?
J

According to the core rules, the TWF feat only applies to melee weapons. This isn't something the Sage made up.

Check page 100 of the PHB, under the Crossbow Descriptions.

Why they decided to include this information in the equipment section instead of the feat section is beyond me, but there it is.
 

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top