Captain America: The First Avenger

Fiery_Dragon

First Post
Went to a screening of Captain America held in Toronto last night.

Quick, non-spoiler review:

Really fun movie, really great Captain America. I wish it was an hour longer, or that we could get another Cap movie or two before The Avengers 'cause there's a lot of story that gets crammed into montages as they skip across WWII.

The interesting thing about this movie, as compared to Iron Man or Thor (or Incredible Hulk) is that Steve Rogers is a true hero, even before he becomes Captain America and gets his supersoldier abilities. Even though this is probably the most violent of the Marvel movies so far, it's the one that I'm most keen to take my kids to because Captain America demonstrates such great qualities.

Anyway, really enjoyed it, lots of fun, wish it was longer, great set-up for Avengers. Chris Evans is excellent.


Longer review, more spoilers...










I think the trick with this movie was cramming Cap's WWII career into one single movie so that he could get frozen by the end to be thawed for The Avengers next year. We spend a fair amount of time with Rogers pre-Super Soldier serum, so we get a lengthy set-up and origin piece, and we have the finale where he ends up in the ice... leaving not a lot of time to his exploits during WWII.

But - the stuff they do show with Cap and the Howling Commandos is great, if quick. All of the Commandos get a quick moment to shine in their action montage, even if the movie never mentions their names (aside from Bucky Barnes), and Captain America is a great man of action. The shield is cool, and used a bunch of different ways, and is almost its own character. The Bucky in the movie is the Bucky Barnes of a future Winter Soldier story rather than the scrappy young sidekick, and it's well done in the film.

There are a lot of great moments of Steve Rogers being noble and heroic - not stuff where he's awesome at jumping on tanks, but stuff where he demonstrates his willingness to sacrifice himself for others or stand up for what he believes in.

The end comes quick. Like I said, I wish we had another hour or another entire movie to see the ongoing battles between Captain America's Howling Commandos and the Red Skull's Hyrdra organization. The ending was good, but I wish it was even more emotional. Bascially, it's the opening scene from the 2009 Stark Trek movie, where the hero is going to sacrifice himself for the greater good while talking with loved ones on the radio, Star Trek was powerful. With Captain America, I was thinking that surely Cap could figure out another option or there must be some other way to save everyone without giving his life... maybe it seemed that he had more time than he should have, I don't know.

Anyway, great rip-roaring adventure film, with a great hero and filled with lots of cool bits that had me wanted much more.

The didn't play the end-credits button at the screening, but I'm pretty sure I'm going to see it again this weekend and catch that, but I'm already excited for The Avengers next year so that's just icing on the cake. Definately hope they keep WWII stuff in any sequels.

- JB
 

log in or register to remove this ad

[sblock]I wish it was an hour longer, or that we could get another Cap movie or two before The Avengers 'cause there's a lot of story that gets crammed into montages as they skip across WWII...

...leaving not a lot of time to his exploits during WWII...

...Like I said, I wish we had another hour or another entire movie to see the ongoing battles between Captain America's Howling Commandos and the Red Skull's Hyrdra organization...

...Definately hope they keep WWII stuff in any sequels.[/sblock]

I wouldn't be surprised to see, for example, an short animated spin-off series that more thoroughly explores those exploits. In fact, I'd almost be disappointed if they didn't.
 

Captain America is my favorite superhero. And I've been excited about this movie for years.

But I have two fears:

1- Hollywood and patriotism and non-flawed heroes. I fear that Hollywood will not feel comfortable with Steve Rogers' patriotism and heroic personality. I fear Hollywood will have to . . . twist? . . . these aspects of Captain America to "make the story more compelling".

2- The comic book Captain America started out pretty cheesy, I know. But he has, over the decades, become more than the cheesy punch-Hitler-in-the-jaw character. I fear Hollywood will make the movie extremely cheesy and the defense will be, "Well, Captain America was really cheesy back in the day."

Does the movie go these routes?

Bullgrit
 


The movie is extremely patriotic. I love their use of many of the traditional symbols of that time and incoperating them into the movie. The only flaws Captain was given is his inability to get drunk and the ability to talk to women.
 

Captain America is my favorite superhero. And I've been excited about this movie for years.

He's probably my second favorite after Spider-man, so I've been looking forward to this one.

Does the movie go these routes?

I say no, and I really liked it.

My only real disappointment would be wanting more like Fiery_Dragon, I think it was about forty minutes in when he finally got his powers.

And the one problem I thought of while typing the above is that Hydra's tech felt out of place, even if it is appropriate relative to the comics.
 


Captain America is my favorite superhero. And I've been excited about this movie for years.

But I have two fears:

1- Hollywood and patriotism and non-flawed heroes. I fear that Hollywood will not feel comfortable with Steve Rogers' patriotism and heroic personality. I fear Hollywood will have to . . . twist? . . . these aspects of Captain America to "make the story more compelling".

2- The comic book Captain America started out pretty cheesy, I know. But he has, over the decades, become more than the cheesy punch-Hitler-in-the-jaw character. I fear Hollywood will make the movie extremely cheesy and the defense will be, "Well, Captain America was really cheesy back in the day."

Does the movie go these routes?

Bullgrit

Have no fear.

The interesting thing about the movie, from a meta perspective, is that unlike Tony Stark and Thor who need to discover humility or find a cause greater than themselves, that's Steve Rogers STARTING position. He doesn't have to undergo the hero's journey - he's already there. It's more about gaining the abilities to match his existing heroic qualities.

As for the cheesey punch-Hitler bits, they address that in the movie, very cleverly. "Captain America" is super cheesy, but Steve Rogers isn't and rescues him from that fate.

- JB
 

As for the cheesey punch-Hitler bits, they address that in the movie, very cleverly. "Captain America" is super cheesy, but Steve Rogers isn't and rescues him from that fate.


Along with Hayley Atwell, that entire tack is what I loved best about the movie. It's like they completely anticipated that concern and addressed it in the most excellent way one could imagine.
 


Remove ads

Top