replicant2
First Post
ColonelHardisson said:Same here. I find Howard's work bright, energetic, two-fisted, and the epitome of purple prose. It's lush and dreamy at times, and keen and quick as a sword-stroke at other times. Tolkien's writing is erudite and cleanly elegant, and has a certain weight to it, gravitas, that the great myths and epics have. Both writers' styles are very different, but both are supremely readable.
I wouldn't say one is a better writer than the other. Howard has a natural ability, a kind of raw talent, that leaps off the page as if alive. Tolkien has the stately bearing of a scholar, supremely comfortable with the language and capable of creating great wonders with it. Howard's action scenes are like whirlwinds, where Tolkien's action scenes are like a richly detailed painting one can only catch a few beathless glimpses of in passing.
I like your thinking, very well thought-out and I would agree.