Couple creation spell questions...

[Kerrick]

Got a question: If I wanted to create a mass of, say, ice, using a minor or major creation spell, what category would it fall under? I'm kind of leaning toward mineral...

What about flesh? Say I want to create a roughyly humanoid body, which I could then polymorph into whatever form I wanted (say, to make an unliving clone of myself). Where would that one fall?

 

[mercucio]

You cannot create flesh or ice as neither fall into the any of the categories of material that major and minor creation allow you to create.

That is a strict interpretation of the spell description. To be honest, I'd make ice the same as vegetable matter and animal flesh the same as stone/crystal/base metals.