cross gender fun?

have you ever played a character of the opposite gender?

  • yes

    Votes: 189 72.1%
  • no

    Votes: 59 22.5%
  • are you kidding? i feel restrained by having just 2 genders to choose from!

    Votes: 14 5.3%

Re: Quite Right...

Mark Chance said:


...
I couldn't help but wonder why he (who is about my age of mid-30s) is gaming with a 17-year-old.
Dude! Even Gary Gygax himself is constantly playing with people who are his junior by far - so there! ;)

(Myself, I'm 24 and my players are also in their early 20s. And I let them play whichever gender they choose, of course.)
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Of course there are mature 17-year-olds, but you are playing an odds-game to a certain extent, which is why I really believe in individual assesements of gaming potential.
 

Re: Re: Quite Right...

Darkness said:
Dude! Even Gary Gygax himself is constantly playing with people who are his junior by far - so there! ;)


I've met Gygax. I found him to be an offensive little troll of a man not too far removed from the average 17-year-old. Maybe he was just having an off-night, but regaling convention goers with tales of hiring Hustler centerfolds to frolic nearly nude with his teenage son and the son's friends do not engender much in the way of respect from me.

I forget the author, but whoever he was had a wonderful definition of "celebrity": someone who is famous for being famous. :)

My players' ages range from mid-20s to late-40s. Almost all of us have at least our bachelor's degrees, half of us are veterans, and one is an ex-cop. Most of us are married. Half of us have children. All in all, I don't imagine we're the typical gaming group. Also, since I teach middle school, I want nothing to do with teenagers during my leisure time. :)
 

Heh. Yeah, that was kinda my point (hidden under a healthy dose of sarcasm, of course :p): Not every 17-year-old has to be immature - just like not every 64-year-old has to mature. ;) But in most cases, they are. :)

Still, one could also say that my main point was fooling around a bit... :D
 

LostSoul said:


Implicit in this statement is that men do violence casually and for entertainment; that men do not need to get "real worked up" or invested before they get violent, and that it's for fun. I don't think you meant to attack men, but your statement could easily be seen that way.


Implicit in the genre of D&D is the understanding that killing things and taking their stuff is fun. Combat is a hoot. Run a scenario that goes too long without a combat and most players will start to get antsy about when they get to hit something.

Now, obviously there are men who don't enjoy pretending about violence and women who do, no gender rule is absolute. But in general the typical D&D player is male, and the sales materials are geared towards a male clientel. So you tell me, do guys find combat, (pretend combat anyway), amusing? I would hazard a guess that most do.

I can count the nonviolent, pacifist PCs I have encountered on one finger. And I ran her, and I can tell you that the system, it's not set up to support her kind. You don't get levels without killing stuff and collecting their treasure. And you get up the party's nose real quick, because even if you are willing to make that sacrifice, most others aren't.

D&D rewards violent resolution to conflicts. The pure satisfaction of engaing in problem solving behaviors that are not acceptable in the "real world" is a fundamental part of the escapist fantasy.
 

Yay Violence!

Originally posted by Sialia So you tell me, do guys find combat, (pretend combat anyway), amusing?

Of course I do. I'm a man. :)

I also enjoy boxing, kickboxing, and other combative contact sports (but not professional so-called wrestling).
 



Bran Blackbyrd said:


Which internet did you think you were posting on? :)

now THAT'S funny! but seriously, i thought it would bring out fun stories about gender slips and roleplaying 8 month long elven menstruation and such....
 


Remove ads

Top