P Pierson_Lowgal First Post Jun 30, 2008 #21 The way shield etc... works clearly indicates that GMs tell PCs the attack roll. The podcast and video podcast confirm that Chris Perkins & Dave Noonan tell the PCs the numbers.
The way shield etc... works clearly indicates that GMs tell PCs the attack roll. The podcast and video podcast confirm that Chris Perkins & Dave Noonan tell the PCs the numbers.
K KarinsDad Adventurer Jun 30, 2008 #22 Lurker37 said: THE DMG goes into the pros and cons of the DM rolling in the open vs behind a DM screen. Click to expand... I was surprised that the DMG almost treated this subject objectively. Previous DMGs (and this one as well) tend to have a lot of terminology which implies "an only or best way to play the game". This one was a lot more even handed in this case. However, that entire section has a lot of "best ways" and "don'ts" it.
Lurker37 said: THE DMG goes into the pros and cons of the DM rolling in the open vs behind a DM screen. Click to expand... I was surprised that the DMG almost treated this subject objectively. Previous DMGs (and this one as well) tend to have a lot of terminology which implies "an only or best way to play the game". This one was a lot more even handed in this case. However, that entire section has a lot of "best ways" and "don'ts" it.