TheBlueKnight
Explorer
Where can one find old copies of the magazines? I have the 4e issues from DnD Insider but the stuff from 1e-3.5e I don't have. Are they available electronically somehow?
Thanks in advance.
Thanks in advance.
Where can one find old copies of the magazines? I have the 4e issues from DnD Insider but the stuff from 1e-3.5e I don't have. Are they available electronically somehow?
Thanks in advance.
As a writer for 4e Dungeon I have to disagree; while I think there was a bit of an initial dip, by 2009-2010 the magazine was regularly producing high quality adventures.
I went through my 4th ed Dugneons last week from that era (2010) looking for maps to use and I had just looked at the final Paizo era Dungeons and ran the War of the Wielded adventure. The 4E PDFs are not even in the same league as a lot of the maps look like badly arranged tiles. The cartography is le suck.
I actually usually have the opposite approach; I made extensive use of Dragon but I usually skipped over Dungeon since it was mostly adventures, which is good and all but not what I was interested in content-wise (since I generally engineer my own adventures).
I'm not going to dispute that maps created from Dungeon Tiles aren't that attractive, but there are plenty of good adventures, especially after WotC abandoned the tactical encounter format.
Feel free to recommend a few up to the end of 2010. Were you familiar with Dungeon in the final days of 3.5? At the time thats what I compared the 4E Dungeon to and that was probably the apex of 3.5 adventure design with the Savage Tide AP.
Every issue of Dungeon is worth getting. Dragon is much more variable, with earlier issues being more generally useful and later ones being more edition-dependent.
A little bit of A and a bit of B. I still have tons of 1E Dragons, but mostly 3E Dungeons. For Dragon, that's because I definitely preferred the 1E/2E content to 3E/4E content -- and hope 5E Dragon looks more "old school". For Dungeon, it's a matter of being a hard-core home-brewer; I didn't need published adventures until I had a 40 hour job and kids. I still have a shelf full of 3E Dungeons, though, that'll get updated for 5E, as needed.I actually usually have the opposite approach; I made extensive use of Dragon but I usually skipped over Dungeon since it was mostly adventures, which is good and all but not what I was interested in content-wise (since I generally engineer my own adventures).
I'd guess that the style of adventure presentation (emphasis on encounters) has more to do with any disparaging of 4E Dragon. I think the writers typically did what was asked of them, well enough. Maybe that's what you mean, though.As a writer for 4e Dungeon I have to disagree; while I think there was a bit of an initial dip, by 2009-2010 the magazine was regularly producing high quality adventures.