• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

[EU] So, what in EU is worth it

Nothing major HAS been nullified by the movies. Not even the clone use in the Thrawn trilogy...as that was obviously using a different method than the Kaminoans do. In the Thrawn Trilogy, Spaarti Cloning Cylindars were used, and those didn't have nearly the same kind of success rate that the Kaminoan ones did.

Honestly, the only two things I can think of that have been downright nullified are Boba Fett's background(which had four or five different versions anyway) and the details on the Death Star's construction.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Ankh-Morpork Guard said:
Nothing major HAS been nullified by the movies. Not even the clone use in the Thrawn trilogy...as that was obviously using a different method than the Kaminoans do. In the Thrawn Trilogy, Spaarti Cloning Cylindars were used, and those didn't have nearly the same kind of success rate that the Kaminoan ones did.

Honestly, the only two things I can think of that have been downright nullified are Boba Fett's background(which had four or five different versions anyway) and the details on the Death Star's construction.
Even then, only some of the details of the Death Star's construction. It's still perfectly feasible that Tarkin had his little secret Maw facility working on a lot of the technical problems the Geonosians didn't work out or places where the Empire thought they could improve upon the design. The basic idea that the Death Star's operating philosophy was the Tarkin Doctrine, to rule by fear of force rather than the use of force by presenting such a powerful weapon that no defense is possible is still valid. Building it in the Horuz system, over Despayre is still valid, and the secret Maw installation in the Kessel system is still valid as a place for some early prototype work and R&D on the design.

Also, note that the Kaminoan clones did take some quite som time to grow and mature, just like Spaarti grown clones (without Yslimiri help), the movies never implied that you could just pop out clone armies with the push of a button. Spaarti technology may be a different implementation than Kaminoan cloning, but the basic ideas don't contradict.

In general, I think the prequels were quite kind to the EU in not contradicting anything major. Even the controversial Dark Empire series was supported by Palpatine's declaration that he knew a way to cheat death (I know some people hate DE, but right there in the movie he says he knows how to cheat death, and the believed-dead villain returning is a staple of pulp adventure, which Star Wars tries to be). Only Boba Fett's backstory (of which there were already several conflicting stories) was really ignoring the EU.

The Prequels actually took a few things that were originally created for the EU and made them Canon. The name Coruscant was created by Timothy Zahn for Heir to the Empire and the rest of the Thrawn novels, and Lucas decided to adopt it (replacing his original idea of calling the city-world capitol of the Empire either Jhantor or Had Abbadon). Some fans like to look down on the EU as not canon (which by the strictest of definitions, it isn't), but Lucas himself is well aware of what's in the EU, the general direction things take, and he has exercised veto power over plot developments he disapproved of (Joruus C'boath was originally going to be a clone of Obi-Wan, but Lucas said no way). The EU may not be strict canon, but Lucas paid attention to it in creating the prequels.
 


Perhaps someone could recommend a couple of books that expand on the prequels (particularly RotS) for me - I've picked up from the various threads that Shatterpoint and Labyrinth of Evil are a good start. Any others I should be reading?
 

I could be wrong, but i seem to remember reading somewhere in the EU that the Emperor cut off Vader's hand as punishment for losing the first Death Star. That's obviously in contrast to the prequel, but i can't recall where i read it.
 


Nebulous said:
I could be wrong, but i seem to remember reading somewhere in the EU that the Emperor cut off Vader's hand as punishment for losing the first Death Star. That's obviously in contrast to the prequel, but i can't recall where i read it.
That was in Dark Force Rising. It's one of a few inconsistencies between the EU and the prequels. This is an easily forgettable inconsistency, however, just like 90% of them.

Kane
 

Nebulous said:
I could be wrong, but i seem to remember reading somewhere in the EU that the Emperor cut off Vader's hand as punishment for losing the first Death Star. That's obviously in contrast to the prequel, but i can't recall where i read it.
It was in the Thrawn Trilogy. Mara Jade tells this to Luke Skywalker.

As for the EU, I also can only recommend the Thrawn Trilogy (Heir to the Empire, Dark Force Rising, and The Last Command). That series was phenomenal! I went on and tried the Kevin J. Anderson books when they came out, but they were . . . not as good. They cured me of delving any further into the EU.
 

wingsandsword said:
Even the controversial Dark Empire series was supported by Palpatine's declaration that he knew a way to cheat death (I know some people hate DE, but right there in the movie he says he knows how to cheat death, and the believed-dead villain returning is a staple of pulp adventure, which Star Wars tries to be).

The problem with DE is that it invalidates Anakin Skywalker as the one who would bring Balance to the Force, and guts the ending of Jedi. Unforgivable crimes IMO. If Vader didn't destroy the Emperor and renounce the Sith then the prophecy wasn't fufilled, when Lucas explicitly says it was. I mean I could see if a new Sith or a new breed of Darksiders rose generations later or something like that. But Dark Empire was what five years after Jedi? And Luke going to the dark side himself in an attempt to destroy it from within? Please! Force Storms destroying fleets? Come on! Dark Empire is just horrid and my hate knows no limit! :D
 


Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top