Evolution (Project Cancelled)

[Steel_Wind]

And how do you know how much time the judges spent looking at each product? You're only assuming that, because you didn't get a nomination, they obviously didn't look at your product for long enough. Can you just not accept that they spent a lot of time with your product(and the other software) and STILL felt that the other products were better?

Ankh - while Vascant is obviously quite emotional about this matter, his concern appears to be born out of tracking the registrations that went with the software.

As he indicated, only one judge registered the software. So it's a little hard for him to accept that it was tested by all of the judges - and tested thoroughly.

If I have misunderstood the issue - Vascant can (and should) state his information on the point succinctly.

 

[Vascant]

To be honest, it doesn't matter anymore or what I think. After all if I am not going to do the ENnies anymore then why even discuss them. A couple of months ago I wanted to get out of selling software and such but yeah I let my ego get the better of me and some people convinced me we should go for an ENnie. I don't blame them and in truth I don't even blame the judges, I blame myself first and foremost because I made that decision. No one held a gun to my head.

So don't worry, in a couple of months you won't even remember NPC Designer existed. Consider this matter closed for me because I won't be back to read anymore

 

[ThirdWizard]

As he indicated, only one judge registered the software. So it's a little hard for him to accept that it was tested by all of the judges - and tested thoroughly.

If I have misunderstood the issue - Vascant can (and should) state his information on the point succinctly.

Cthulu's Librarian implies that multiple judges registered it.

Vascant, please see my reply here, and the email I have sent you. We did evaluate NPC Designer, and regester. I have received confirmation from other judges on this, and I regestered my copy and used it.

Diaglo then said he registered it as well and tested it.

yeah my goof. when you mentioned we didn't register i thought you had sent us the faulty product. but now that i've compared titles, CL is correct. i registered your product and used it too. several times in fact.

I'd say other Judges most likely tried it out as well, though I have no proof.


On the Sunless Citadel thing, that was a misunderstanding, as noted by Rasyr in that same thread.

I have had it brought to my attention (in a very round-about manner), that the actual category name is "Best Campaign/Campaign Supplement", not "Best Campaign Setting/Setting Supplement" as the announcement flyer states.

So there ya go, FWIW.