Fighter question

[Liquidsabre]

Interestingly enough, a Swashbuckler has Profession as a class skill for those sailor-fighter types heh.

 

[ruleslawyer]

This still doesn't explain why most other PC classes have profession as a class skill then. Can you justify Profession: Sailor, Miner, Driver, Farmer, Teamster, Stablehand (examples which are explicitly mentioned in the PHB) better for, say, wizards than fighters?

This is the crux of the issue. Why should a wizard, cleric, or hell, even a rogue have greater facility at learning a profession than a fighter? A wizard is no less a specialist than a fighter; in fact, it might be argued that a wizard has to spend more time studying spellbooks and sleeping than the fighter does at weapons practice.

I say either give Profession to all PC classes, or make it a class skill for NPC classes only.