Creamsteak
Explorer
it appears you're going to have the Red Mage play some role different than his normal FF1 or FF5 roles
No. Not unless you don't agree with me that the red mage traditionally used lesser black and white magic, and had a medium rank as a front line fighter.
Further, you're implying anyone can start out as a monk, thief, warrior, or other color mage, but to be a chemist requires leveling as a mage
Monk, thief, fighter, red mage, black mage, white mage are the core classes in this design; all of these classes are on call from ff1. I kinda like using the original game as the core for the others. Chemists create and control magic items in quite a few ways. This is a DnD conversion, not just a d20 conversion, so spellcasting should remain requisite of item creation.
In my opinion.
First of all, why should the Black Mage and Black Wizard and the White Mage and White Wizard be separate? [and Red Mage and Red Wizard]
I'm still thinking about this. It makes sense on a progression based level, and theres ways to do it mechanically. However, the Fieari summarizes my feelings about the wording more precisely. "Why would?" unless I pigeonhole a class which is the opposite of what I want to do. Of course, who would rather be called a warrior instead of a knight either, except if warrior implies additional versitility over being a heavy armored swordsman.
I've detailed other versions of the project; I've worked with variants that you might appreciate more. This version is sort of an attempt to have clarity from the organization standpoint without forcing the classes through class loops like Final Fantasy Tactics.