I love the scare quotes.
We're so close to release date that worrying about what they're going to do is kinda moot. We'll find out what's what and what's rumor soon.
I love the scare quotes.
In my experience, the monsters are typically grouped in small clumps and the PCs are tightly clustered when the attack begins. Therefore, it's easier and faster for the players to set up flanking than for the monsters. So I would guess this approach is likely to lead to flanking being used by the players only, without the monsters getting the chance to retaliate.I might try making it so that you can't flank someone if you yourself are flanked.
My biggest problem with flanking was when running into people who just thought it was the general rule (my bet is that they came from 3.5, or from 5e games under DMs who came from 3.5).
I think that 5e quite effectively models how screwed you can be when you're outnumbered, without adding an unnecessary mechanic to it. I'm fine with no flanking. I'm a little more concerned with no optional rules at all, if only because I like variant rules to exist, even if I don't tend to use them.
OTOH, I'd be happy for a big ol' kitbashing book to come out separately (though I don't expect it) and for the DMG to be pure base "this is how most people do it".
The 2024 DMG is 384 pages while the 2014 one is 320 pages. So they've already won my good will by increasing the amount of content while not even raising the price despite 10 years of rather high inflation.
The font is bigger and there's more art. The 2024 PHB has more pages but fewer words than the 2014 PHB.
You have the word count?
What is it?
Also, I love art and greatly appreciate that there is more of it.