Agent Oracle
First Post
Perhaps if the actual "Flute" portion was only about 3 or so feet long, and then the outlying 1.5 feet on either side were iron-shod staff good for hitting things? It could stil whistle as you spun it around...
der_kluge said:From a musical standpoint, a 6 foot long "flute" (or fife) would produce indescribably low tones. A bass flute is 146 cm (4'9") in length. Bass flutes are rarely used in modern orchestras (read: almost never) because the tone is basically inaudible, and exceedingly low. A 6 foot variety would sound most "un-flute" like, and in a crowded environment, everyone would have to basically come to a complete silence in order to hear it at all.
Furthermore, a bass flute has a curved mouthpiece so that in order to maintain proper hole distance for the fingers, the mouthpiece was curved back around so that the right hand pinky could actually reach the furthest hand.
A 6 foot long flute/staff with 6 holes, would have the furthest hole some 5 feet away from the actual blowhole. Try this: Measure the distance from your lip to your outstretched right arm's pinky finger. You'll be lucky if it's 3 feet. You can see why such a thing would be impractical.
spacemonkey said:Length certainly isn't the only factor in determining the tonal range of a flute. You have bore size, hole size, etc to fiddle with also. For example, here is a mighty big flute that still plays in the hearable range for humans:
ceratitis said:The bard's tail a.k.a the whispering flute
At a glance this simply looks like a wooden staff of about 5 ft. those with sharp eyes (spot DC 17) will notice that half way down its length it has holes fit for use as a flute by a medium sized human.
It is in fact hollow all the way through and thus can be used as an effective blowgun. This however weakens the staff so in order to make it usable as a melee weapon it is made from Darkwood. Obviously to make such a weapon takes great skill and possibly magic as well. It functions as a master work flute, staff, and blowgun. Its light weight also enables it to be finesseble and used as a monk weapon.
When wielded as a staff a weird sound effect is created which can be used by a skillful combatant (BAB +6, 7 ranks in perform, must own staff for a week before this can be implemented) to grant a +2 competence bonus to bluff on attempting a feint.
The MW flute can be used while telling stories, preferably by the fire, to emphasis and create sound effects granting to a perform roll a +2 bonus for using a masterwork tool.
The blowgun may be used while performing bardic music, however this tricky maneuver allows only one shot regardless of anything that may increase the number of allowed attacks and requires a perform check of DC 20 to succeed. Failure incurs a -6 to the attack roll and ends the bardic song.
Of course! Why not? That's a fantasy game we're playing.Presto2112 said:In Kill Bill Vol. 2, Bill carried around a huge flute, seemingly carved from a large bamboo shoot or something. Do you think that it would be feasible for a PC to carry on of those around and, if made of a strong enough material (adamantine, mithril, steel, etc) to also double it as a quarterstaff-type weapon? Or would it be too fragile even constructed of such a material?
From Wikipedia:woodelf said:Nitpick 1: I'm pretty certain that one end of a flute needs to be closed for it to work. So it can't be hollow all the way through. Of course, that may be more realism than is needed for such a weapon/instrument.
Staffan said:From Wikipedia:
Flutes may be open on one or both of their ends. The ocarina, pan pipes, police whistle, and bosun's whistle are closed-ended. Open-ended flutes such as the concert flute and the recorder have more harmonics, and thus more flexibility for the player, and brighter timbres. An organ pipe may be either open or closed, depending on the sound desired.